|
|
|
1 Center for Developmental Biology, Department of Zoology, University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712 USA; 2 Wellcome/Cancer Research Campaign (CRC) Institute of Cancer and Developmental Biology, Cambridge CB2 1QR, UK
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Mutations in the mouse indicate that quaking gene function is essential for both embryogenesis and for development of the nervous system. Recent isolation of the mouse quaking gene identified a putative RNA-binding protein containing a single KH domain. We have previously isolated the Xenopus homolog of quaking, Xqua, and shown that the sequence is highly conserved through evolution. Here, we report experimental data on the biochemical function of the quaking protein and its role during development. We demonstrate that the quaking protein expressed during early embryogenesis, pXqua357, can bind RNA in vitro, and we have mapped the regions of the protein that are essential for RNA binding. We present evidence that pXqua can form homodimers and that dimerization may be required for RNA binding. Oocyte injection experiments show that pXqua357 is located in both the nucleus and cytoplasm. In the Xenopus embryo, Xqua is first expressed during gastrulation in the organizer region and its derivative, the notochord. In later stage embryos, Xqua is expressed in a number of mesodermal and neural tissues. We demonstrate that disruption of normal Xqua function, by overexpression of a dominant inhibitory form of the protein, blocks notochord differentiation. Xqua function appears to be required for the accumulation of important mRNAs such as Xnot, Xbra, and gsc. These results indicate an essential role for the quaking RNA-binding protein during early vertebrate embryogenesis.
[Key Words: quaking; Xqua; KH domain; RNA binding; notochord; Xenopus]
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The function of the murine quaking
gene product is required both during embryogenesis and during later
development of the nervous system as indicated by two classes of mutant
recessive quaking alleles. Mice that are homozygous for the
quaking viable allele
(qkv/qkv) have a deficiency
of myelin in their nervous system and exhibit a characteristic tremor
or "quaking" of the hind quarters (Sidman etal. 1964; Samorajski
et al. 1970
). The second class of quaking alleles,
qke1-4/qke1-4, are
embryonic lethal around day 9-10 of gestation (Bode 1984
; Justice and
Bode 1988
; Shedlovsky et al. 1988
). The mutant embryos are disorganized
and exhibit generalized atrophy, but the precise cause of lethality has
not been characterized (Justice and Bode 1988
).
The sequence of the recently cloned mouse quaking gene (qkI)
(Ebersole et al. 1996
) and its human (Hqk) and
Xenopus (Xqua) homologs (Zorn et al. 1997
) indicate
that quaking encodes a KH domain RNA-binding protein. The KH
domain is an evolutionarily conserved sequence found in a diversity of
proteins, most of which are implicated in some aspect of RNA metabolism
(Gibson et al. 1993
; Siomi et al. 1993a
). Notable examples include the
heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein K (hnRNP K) (Siomi et al.
1993a
) and the human Fragile X Syndrome gene, FMR1 (Siomi et al.
1993b
). Experimental evidence indicates that the KH domain is directly involved in RNA binding. For example, a particularly severe allele of
the Fragile X Syndrome (De Boulle et al. 1993
) is caused by a single
point mutation in a conserved residue in the second KH domain,
resulting in a mutant protein that shows dramatically reduced
RNA-binding activity (Siomi et al. 1994
). quaking belongs to a
new subclass of KH proteins, called GSG domain proteins (Jones and
Schedl 1995
; Ebersole et al. 1996
), based on sequence similarity with
GLD-1, a tumor suppressor gene required for germ line
development in Caenorhabditis elegans (Jones and Schedl 1995
);
SAM68, a mammalian phosphoprotein involved in the Src
signaling pathways during mitosis (Won et al. 1992; Fumagalli et al.
1994
; Taylor and Shalloway 1994
; Lock et al. 1996
); and
GRP33, an hnRNP isolated from brine shrimp (Cruz-Alvarez
and Pellicer 1987
). GSG proteins are characterized by an
~200-amino-acid region of sequence similarity centered on a single
KH motif. Although the KH domain is highly conserved between GSG family
members, it is rather divergent from the KH motifs found in other
proteins.
The qkv defect is a classic model for the study of
dismyelination, and a wealth of literature describes various aspects of the defective nervous system (Hogan and Greenfield 1984
). Despite this
intense investigation, the precise role of quaking in neural development remains obscure, and even less is understood about its
function during early embryogenesis. The mouse qkI gene
produces three transcripts 5 kb, 6 kb, and 7 kb in length, generated by alternative mRNA splicing. The sequences of the proteins resulting from
these transcripts are identical except for the extreme carboxy-terminal region (Ebersole et al. 1996
). In Xenopus, 5-kb and 5.5-kb
mRNAs (analogous to the mouse 5-kb and 6-kb mRNAs) have been observed (Zorn et al. 1997
). In both frog and mouse only the 5-kb mRNA is
expressed in the early embryo, with the 6-kb form arising later in
development. Expression of the 5-kb and 6-kb sequences continues throughout development, and in the adult mouse, the transcripts are
abundant in the brain, lung, heart, and testis (Ebersole et al. 1996
).
Expression of the 7-kb mRNA is apparently restricted to the adult
brain. The fact that qkI is expressed in a variety of tissues
and that quaking mutations have pleiotropic effects suggests
that quaking function is important for the development or
maintenance of a number of cell types. Furthermore, the remarkable 94%
conservation of the mouse, human, and Xenopus protein
sequences (Zorn et al. 1997
) suggests that the quaking
biochemical pathway is highly conserved through evolution.
A number of KH domain RNA-binding proteins are known to be required
during development of invertebrates. These include Bicaudal-C in Drosophila, which is essential for anterior-posterior
specification (Mahone et al. 1995
); gld-1, which encodes a GSG
protein that is essential for germ line development in C. elegans (Jones and Schedl 1995
); and mex-3, which
regulates early blastomere identity in the C. elegans embryo
(Draper et al. 1996
). quaking is one of the first examples of
a KH domain protein essential for early vertebrate embryogenesis. In an
effort to understand the developmental function of the quaking protein,
we have characterized the biochemical properties of pXqua357,
the Xenopus quaking protein that is expressed during early
embryonic development. We have mapped the regions of pXqua357
that are essential for RNA binding and present evidence that pXqua
proteins can form homodimers. These results have implications not only
for quaking but also for understanding the general biochemical properties of the GSG subfamily of KH domain proteins. Finally, we
demonstrate that embryonic overexpression of pXqua357
enhances notochord development, whereas overexpression of a dominant inhibitory pXqua mutant disrupts the endogenous Xqua pathway
and blocks notochord development. The normal function of Xqua
appears to be essential for the accumulation of important mRNAs such as Xnot, Xbra, and goosecoid (gsc). Our
findings provide a possible explanation for the early embryonic
lethality of quaking mutant embryos.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
pXqua binds RNA in vitro
The presence of a KH motif in the quaking protein (Ebersole et al.
1996
; Zorn et al. 1997
) suggests that it is an RNA-binding protein. To
directly test this possibility, we have examined the in vitro
RNA-binding properties of Xenopus quaking proteins
pXqua357 and pXqua365, which are identical except
for an 8-amino-acid insertion just carboxy-terminal to the GSG domain,
generated by alternative splicing (Zorn et al. 1997
) (Fig.
1A). In vitro 35S-labeled Xqua proteins
were assayed for the ability to bind RNA immobilized on agarose beads
(Swanson and Dreyfuss 1988
). As shown in Figure 1B, both
pXqua357 and pXqua365 bind total Xenopus
embryonic RNA but do not bind significantly to agarose alone. We
examined whether pXqua had a preference for the type of RNA it would
bind by using different RNA homopolymers coupled to agarose. Both
pXqua357 and pXqua365 bind preferentially to
poly(rG) and poly(rU) RNA, whereas neither binds significantly to
poly(rA) or poly(rC) RNA (Fig. 1B), indicating that pXqua has some
specificity in its interaction with RNA. Because pXqua357 and
pXqua365 exhibit indistinguishable RNA-binding properties in
this assay, only pXqua357 was used in subsequent experiments.
The strength of the RNA-protein interactions was examined by
increasing the salt concentration of the binding assay. As shown in
Figure 1C, recombinant pXqua357 binds weakly to total
embryonic RNA and poly(rU), neither interaction being stable in 250 mM NaCl. However, pXqua357 shows a much stronger
interaction with poly(rG) RNA, retaining some binding up to 500 mM. In additional experiments, pXqua357 exhibited
weak binding to single-stranded DNA-agarose, but no detectable binding
to double-stranded DNA-agarose (data not shown). The nucleic acid
binding properties of pXqua are comparable with those of RNA-binding
proteins reported previously (Piñol-Roma et al. 1987
; Swanson and
Dreyfuss 1988
; Siomi et al. 1993b
).
|
The KH domain and the carboxy-terminal region are required for RNA binding in vitro
quaking and the other members of the GSG subfamily are
characterized by a single KH motif. They are therefore distinct from most previously studied KH proteins that contain multiple KH motifs (Gibson et al. 1993
; Siomi et al. 1993a
,b
). Detailed RNA-binding studies of hnRNP K and FMR1, for example, have shown that cooperativity between the multiple KH domains is required for full RNA binding and
that deletion of any one KH motif practically abolishes RNA-binding activity (Siomi et al. 1994
). In light of this, it is important to
determine which regions of pXqua are required for its RNA-binding activity. We therefore generated a series of truncated pXqua proteins (Fig. 2A) and assayed for in vitro RNA-binding
activity (Fig. 2B). Truncation of the amino-terminal region up to the
KH domain (
B) caused only a slight reduction in RNA-binding
activity (to 75% of wild-type levels). In contrast, deletion of either
the core KH domain (
D) or the carboxy-terminal region (
A)
resulted in severe loss of RNA-binding activity, demonstrating that
both of these regions are essential for maximal RNA-binding activity. Consistent with this observation,
C, which contains the KH domain but not the carboxy-terminal region, and
E, which contains the carboxy-terminal region alone, exhibit no RNA-binding activity in this
assay. In an attempt to further define the sequences in the
carboxy-terminal region required for RNA binding, two additional truncated proteins,
F and
G, were tested. Neither of these
proteins shows significant RNA-binding activity. We conclude that both the KH domain and sequences in the carboxy-terminal region are essential for the RNA-binding activity of pXqua357.
Examination of the carboxy-terminal sequence, however, does not reveal
the presence of any previously described RNA-binding motif.
|
pXqua can form homodimers
How is it possible for pXqua, with only one KH domain, to bind RNA, whereas other KH proteins such as hnRNP K and FMR1 need multiple KH motifs? One possibility is that two or more pXqua monomers might physically interact, thus allowing multiple KH domains to cooperate in RNA binding. We therefore tested the ability of pXqua357 monomers to physically interact, using two different experimental approaches: first, coimmunoprecipitation (Fig. 3A) and, second, binding reactions using bacterial glutathione S-transferase (GST) fusion proteins (Fig. 3B). For immunoprecipitation experiments, synthetic mRNAs encoding a hemagglutinin (HA) epitope-tagged version of pXqua, pHA-Xqua357 and pXqua357 (with no HA tag) were cotranslated in a reticulocyte lysate (Fig. 3A, lane 5). Immunoprecipitation using an anti-HA antibody resulted in the precipitation of pHA-Xqua357 and the coprecipitation of pXqua357 (Fig. 3A, lane 8), indicating that pHA-Xqua357 and pXqua357 monomers are physically associated. Control immunoprecipitation of translations containing pXqua357 alone did not result in a detectable product (lane 7). Furthermore, when Anti-HA immunoprecipitations were performed on the cotranslation of pHA-Xqua357 and an irrelevant protein (pFR), only pHA-Xqua357 was detected (lanes 4 and 6). These immunoprecipitation results were confirmed using GST-Xqua protein binding experiments. Purified GST or GST-Xqua was immobilized on glutathione-Sepharose and then incubated with 35S-labeled pXqua357 or the control KH domain protein hnRNP K. After washing, the bound proteins were analyzed by SDS-PAGE. As shown in Figure 3B, labeled pXqua357 binds to the GST-Xqua fusion protein but not to GST alone. As expected, the hnRNP K control protein does not bind to either GST or GST-Xqua. Overall, these results demonstrate that pXqua357 monomers are capable of forming physical complexes. The simplest interpretation is that two pXqua monomers interact to form a homodimer, but these experiments do not exclude the possibility of oligomeric complexes containing more than two pXqua monomers.
|
pXqua357 is both cytoplasmic and nuclear
A role for KH domain proteins has been suggested at many levels of
RNA metabolism from pre-mRNA processing to translational regulation
(Gibson et al. 1993
). To obtain some information concerning the
possible function of pXqua357, we examined its subcellular
location using the well-characterized Xenopus oocyte
expression system. Numerous experiments have demonstrated that oocytes
translate microinjected mRNAs and faithfully compartmentalize the
proteins to the correct subcellular location (Colman 1984
). Synthetic
capped mRNA encoding pXqua357, or control sequences encoding
cytoplasmic EF-1
(Krieg et al. 1989
) or nuclear XMax (Tonissen and
Krieg 1994
), were microinjected into Xenopus oocytes. The
results of these experiments (Fig. 4) show that
pXqua357 is located in both the cytosolic and nuclear
compartments. In each of 10 separate injection experiments, ~60% of
the pXqua357 is cytoplasmic, whereas 40% resides in the
nucleus. Examination of controls indicates that 91% of the total
EF-1
protein is in the cytoplasmic fraction, whereas 80% of the
XMax protein is translocated to the nucleus. Because the oocyte nucleus
represents ~4% of the volume of the whole cell, pXqua is
concentrated ~10-fold in the nucleus, relative to a random
distribution. The same nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio is
observed in each experiment, independent of the overall level of pXqua
expression in the oocyte (data not shown), suggesting that its
subcellular distribution is regulated. These experiments suggest that
pXqua357 may have a biological function in both the nuclear
and cytoplasmic compartments.
|
The carboxy-terminal region of pXqua is essential for translocation to the nucleus
Nuclear import/export is a dynamic process that is
regulated tightly (Golbfarb and Michaud 1991
; Powers and Forbes 1994
), and therefore, it is of interest to determine which regions of pXqua357 are responsible for its subcellular location. To
investigate this, we examined the nuclear/cytoplasmic
distribution of several pXqua deletion constructions (Fig.
5A). As shown in Figure 5B, deletion of the KH domain
(
D) does not affect the nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio,
and deletion of amino-terminal residues 1-110 (
B) only moderately
impairs the translocation to the nucleus. The most dramatic effect on
the nuclear/cytoplasmic distribution is observed when the
carboxyl terminus of the protein is deleted. In this case, virtually
all of
A is retained in the cytoplasm, approximately equivalent to
the cytoplasmic control protein EF-1
. Consistent with this
observation,
E, which only contains carboxyl residues 229-357,
behaves identically to the wild-type protein, indicating that the
elements controlling nuclear import are found within this region. To
further define the sequences responsible for nuclear translocation,
F and
G were also expressed in oocytes. The truncated protein
F showed a distribution equivalent to the wild-type pXqua, whereas
deletion of the last 60 amino acids (
G) caused a significant reduction of protein in the nucleus. We note, however, that
G was
not as severely impaired as pXqua
A in its ability to translocate to the nucleus, suggesting that perhaps not all of the sequences required for the correct nuclear/cytoplasmic distribution
of pXqua357 are contained in the carboxy-terminal 60 amino
acids. In no case do we find a significant increase in nuclear pXqua, a
result that would be consistent with the deletion of a nuclear export
or a cytoplasmic retention signal.
|
Initial Xqua expression is localized to the dorsal blastopore lip
In mouse, expression of qkI mRNA is first detected at day
7.5 of gestation, and qke homozygous mutant embryos
die by day 9 of gestation, indicating that early qkI
expression is essential (Justice and Bode 1988
; Ebersole et al. 1996
).
The mutant embryos are smaller than normal and disorganized, but the
exact nature of the defect is not clear. In Xenopus, embryonic
expression of Xqua commences during early gastrulation (Zorn
et al. 1997
), suggesting that Xqua may play a role very early
during development.
Using whole-mount in situ hybridization, we have examined the spatial
pattern of Xqua expression in the frog embryo. As shown in
Figure 6A, the earliest Xqua expression is
detected in the chordamesoderm of the dorsal blastopore lip of the
midgastrula embryo (stage 11). This tissue, which is analogous to the
node in the mouse embryo, is of particular interest because it
differentiates into the notochord, has embryonic organizing activity,
has neural inducing capability, and plays an integral role in the
morphogenesis of the embryo (for review, see Hamburger 1988
). To our
knowledge, this is the first description of a RNA-binding protein that
is localized to the blastopore lip. In late gastrula embryos (stage 13), high levels of Xqua expression are evident in the
notochord, and the original expression domain expands to include the
tissue surrounding the blastopore (Fig. 6B). In neurula embryos,
Xqua expression is maintained in the notochord and the
circumblastoporal region and now also extends to the paraxial mesoderm
and the neuroectoderm (Fig. 6C-E). By the tailbud stage, Xqua
is expressed in various mesodermal and neural tissues (Fig. 6F,G). High
levels of Xqua mRNA are found in the brain and the neural
tube. Expression in the brain is restricted to the proliferative
ventricular layer and the marginal zone where active differentiation
takes place (Fig. 6H). High levels of Xqua are also detected
in the branchial arches and in the developing heart. The tail blastema,
which is known to maintain some embryonic organizer activity (Gont et
al. 1993
), also expresses significant levels of Xqua mRNA.
During this period of development, expression in the notochord and the somites declines, and by the hatched tadpole stage, Xqua
expression is almost exclusively restricted to the head and heart
(Fig. 6I).
|
Overexpression of wild-type and mutant Xqua mRNA disrupts anterior/axial development
Our expression studies show that Xqua is expressed in a
variety of tissues of mesodermal and neural origin. To investigate the
role of Xqua during development of these tissues, we have overexpressed pXqua357 in the embryo by microinjection of
synthetic mRNA and then examined embryos for developmental effects at
the late tailbud stage. Microinjection of mRNA into two ventral
blastomeres (2.5 ng/blastomere) targeted ectopic
Xqua overexpression primarily to regions of the embryo that do
not normally express Xqua, such as the non-neural ectoderm, the ventral mesoderm, or the endoderm. The distribution of the injected
mRNA was monitored by coinjection of mRNA encoding green fluorescent
protein (GFP) (Zernicka-Goetz et al. 1996
) or
-galactosidase as a
lineage marker (data not shown). Ectopic Xqua overexpression in the ventral region had no obvious effects on the development of the
embryo (Table 1). However, targeting overexpression
to regions of the embryo where Xqua is normally expressed, by
microinjection into dorsal blastomeres (1.25-2.5
ng/blastomere), resulted in abnormal anterior
development. At the highest dose of Xqua mRNA (2.5 ng/blastomere) over half of the embryos exhibit features of exaggerated dorsal-anterior development, including expanded hindbrains, reduced cement glands, enlarged eyes, and occasionally duplicated head structures (Fig. 7B; Table 1).
Control injections of an equivalent amount of rRNA into dorsal
blastomeres produced no observable phenotype (Fig. 7A; Table 1). These
data indicate that when pXqua357 is expressed in tissues
where it is not normally present, it has no obvious effects on
development. In contrast, overexpression of pXqua357 in
tissues where it is normally expressed produces developmental defects.
|
|
To further elucidate the role of pXqua in development, we wished to
disrupt its function in the embryo. We chose to overexpress the
D
deletion mutant (Fig. 7C) that lacks the KH domain and exhibits
severely impaired RNA-binding activity (Fig. 2). Because pXqua is able
to form homodimers, the
D mutant should interact with endogenous
pXqua and inhibit the normal biochemical function. To validate the use
of
D as a dominant interfering agent, we have carried out two
sets of experiments: the first demonstrating that
D is able to
dimerize with wild-type pXqua (Fig. 7D) and the second
demonstrating that
D/pXqua heterodimers exhibit
impaired RNA-binding activity (Fig. 7E). The protein binding
experiments presented in Figure 7D show that
D is able to bind to
GST-Xqua at levels equivalent to wild-type pXqua, strongly suggesting
that
D will form heterodimers with endogenous pXqua in the embryo. The in vitro RNA-binding assays presented in Figure 7E show that a
fivefold excess of
D over wild-type pXqua357 reduces RNA
binding to just 35% of control levels. We estimate that our
overexpression protocol will result in at least a 100-fold excess of
D over endogenous pXqua (based on relative RNA levels). Thus,
overexpression of
D in the embryo should effectively inhibit endogenous pXqua function, by interfering with the protein's ability to bind to its in vivo target RNA.
Synthetic mRNA encoding
D was microinjected into either the dorsal
or ventral equatorial region at the four-cell stage, and embryos were
allowed to develop until the late tailbud stage. Dorsal overexpression
of
D resulted in a dose-dependent deletion of
anterior/axial structures. The phenotype ranged from
microcephaly and acephaly at lower doses (0.5-1.25
ng/blastomere) to loss of the entire anterior half of the
embryo at the highest dose (2.5 ng/blastomere) (Fig.
7F-I; Table 1). Spina bifida was also frequently observed in cases
showing severe anterior truncation. Overexpression of
D in ventral
regions resulted in about half of the embryos having tail defects, but
otherwise the morphology was normal. Lineage tracing, using coinjected
GFP of
-galactosidase mRNA, indicates that tail defects only occur
when the majority of injected mRNA is localized to the posterior region
including the ventral circumblastoporal tissue and the tail blastema
(Fig. 7I), both of which normally express Xqua (Fig.
6B,D,F,G). In these cases we observe a disruption of blastopore
closure. When the majority of the injected
D mRNA is localized to
regions of the embryo that do not normally express Xqua, such
as the gut or ectoderm, the embryos develop normally. We therefore
conclude that the
D effects are specific to cells that normally
express Xqua.
We have examined embryos overexpressing pXqua357 and
D
by histology and by whole-mount immunostaining using antibody markers to detect neural tissue, notochord, and somites. Histological sections
and immunostaining show that in control embryos, the anterior end of
the notochord usually terminates in a hook structure just behind the
forebrain (Fig. 8A,G). Dorsal overexpression of Xqua results in an anterior extension of the notochord, in
many cases until it contacts the ventral pharyngeal endoderm (Fig. 8B).
This enhanced development of the anterior chordamesoderm is often
accompanied by a disruption in the overlying neural tissue with the
loss of forebrain features and a single expanded
midbrain/hindbrain vesicle (Fig. 8B,H). In cases where
Xqua overexpression caused a duplication of anterior head
structures such as cement glands or eyes, immunostaining shows a
duplication or forking of the notochord. In a few cases, as many as
three notochords can be seen lying side by side (Fig. 8J). In contrast,
dorsal overexpression of the
D mutant has the opposite effect to
overexpression of wild-type Xqua and caused a deletion of
anterior structures. In microcephalic and acephalic embryos resulting
from overexpression of
D at moderate levels (0.5-1.25
ng/blastomere), the anterior notochord is truncated, and
this is accompanied by a loss of forebrain and facial structures (Fig.
8C). Histology and immunostaining of the more severe anterior
truncations resulting from high-level
D overexpression (2.5 ng/blastomere) show a complete loss of all head
structures and a total absence of the anterior portion of the notochord
as well as a dramatic reduction in neural and somitic tissue (Fig. 8D,
K-M). In most cases a small amount of posterior notochord tissue is
observed in the tip of the tail, which is split in two as a result of
spina bifida (Fig. 8M). Lineage tracing confirmed that the residual
notochord developed in the posterior region of the axial mesoderm that
received a relatively low dose of
D mRNA (data not shown).
|
Xqua is essential for notochord differentiation
Because Xqua is normally expressed in a number of neural
and mesodermal tissues, it is likely that overexpression of
Xqua or
D influences the development of each of these
tissues directly. However, many of the phenotypic effects that we
observe are likely to result from disruption of the normal development
of the chordamesoderm and its derivative, the notochord. In this
case, impaired chordamesoderm development could influence its neural
inducing and embryonic patterning properties, thereby causing defects
in neural tissue and other anterior structures. In practice, we expect
chordamesoderm and notochord tissues to be particularly vulnerable in
these overexpression studies because they are the earliest domains of
Xqua expression in the embryo and levels of most injected mRNA
decline rapidly after gastrulation (Vize et al. 1991
). To simplify
analysis, subsequent experiments have focused on the role of
Xqua in notochord development.
To avoid possible secondary effects that may occur in whole-embryo
studies, the effects of Xqua and
D overexpression on notochord differentiation have been examined in dorsal mesoderm explants. In
these experiments, Xqua or
D mRNA was microinjected into
dorsal blastomeres at the four-cell stage (2.5 ng/blastomere). At early gastrula, the dorsal half of the
mesoderm, which contains the prospective notochord and somites, was
dissected from the embryo, and two of these dorsal mesoderm pieces were
combined and cultured in a saline solution. The results of a typical
experiment are presented in Figure 9. Because
chordamesoderm undergoes convergent extension cell movements, the
external morphology of the explants provides some indication of the
amount of notochord that has differentiated (Fig. 9C,E,G). Dorsal
marginal zone explants from embryos overexpressing Xqua (Fig.
9E) consistently produce more extended structures than control explants
injected with rRNA (Fig. 9C). This result is consistent with the
extended notochords observed in whole embryos overexpressing
Xqua. Conversely, explants from embryos injected with
D
mRNA (Fig. 9G) showed less elongation compared with control explants.
When sibling control embryos had reached tailbud stage, explants were
fixed, sectioned, and immunostained for the presence of notochord
(black) and somite (red). Twelve independent explants from two separate
injection experiments produced consistent results, and a representative
section through a typical explant of each type is shown (Fig. 9D,F,H).
Explants overexpressing Xqua were more elongated but showed
only a slight increase in the total amount of notochord tissue,
~10% more notochord tissue than in control explants (Fig. 9F). It
is possible that the apparent increase in notochord tissue may be owing
to enhanced morphogenic movements. In contrast, in all 12 cases, much
less notochord tissue differentiated in explants overexpressing
D
mRNA, relative to rRNA-injected controls (Fig. 9, cf. D and H).
D
overexpressing explants had ~10% of the amount of notochord found
in control explants. In general, somite differentiation was unaffected
in these experiments. To demonstrate that
D overexpression is
inhibiting notochord development by specifically interfering with
Xqua function, we have performed rescue experiments. In every
case (six explants), notochord development was significantly rescued in
explants coexpressing Xqua and
D (at a 1:1 mRNA ratio)
relative to explants overexpressing
D alone (Fig. 9, cf. D, H, and
I). Rescue explants had on average 50% of the amount of notochord
found in uninjected control explants, up from only 10% found in
D
explants. Similar rescue experiments using whole embryos were
inconclusive owing to the large amount of mRNA required (at least 10 ng) that caused nonspecific gastrulation defects. As a result of the
Xqua and
D overexpression experiments, we conclude that normal
Xqua function is essential for notochord differentiation.
|
Xqua is involved in early stages of notochord specification
Our explant experiments show that Xqua function is
essential for notochord development. To learn more about this effect,
we have investigated whether Xqua is required for terminal
differentiation of the notochord or whether it is functioning during
specification. Because Xqua is expressed early in the prenotochord
tissue during gastrulation, we have looked at the effect of
D
overexpression on early chordamesoderm and notochord specific markers.
Embryos were injected in the two dorsal blastomeres at the four-cell
stage with 2.5 ng/blastomere mRNA encoding the dominant
inhibitor
D or with
D plus
-galactosidase mRNA as a
lineage tracer. Previous experiments have demonstrated that this dose
is sufficient to strongly inhibit notochord differentiation (Figs. 7H,
8M, and 9H). At the gastrula stage, injected embryos were assayed for the following transcripts: (1) Xnot-2 (Gont et al. 1993
),
which marks the early notochord; (2) Xbra (Smith et al. 1991
),
Xenopus bracyhury, which is
expressed in the notochord in late gastrula and is panmesodermal in
early gastrula; and (3) gsc (Cho et al. 1991
), which marks the
dorsal lip and the presumptive prechordal plate mesoderm. The first
morphological effects of
D overexpression are detected at the late
gastrula stage when the embryos exhibit disrupted gastrulation and the
blastopore does not close properly (Fig. 10, cf. A and D, morphology of
control embryos, with B, C, and E, experimental
embryos). Analyis using in situ hybridization indicates that transcript levels for all three markers are severely down-regulated by
D overexpression. In particular, expression of
Xnot-2 and Xbra is completely absent from the dorsal
midline where the notochord would normally form (Fig. 10A-F). Residual Xnot-2 expression is often seen in two lateral patches. These apparently correlate with the two remnant notochords that are often
observed at later stages in the tail of
D-injected embryos (Fig.
8M). Lineage tracing using
-galactosidase activity (Fig. 10C,F,I,L) confirms that the effect is restricted to cells that express
the dominant-negative
D. These results demonstrate that Xqua is acting very early during development of the
chordamesoderm and that pXqua function is required for the accumulation
of several essential mRNAs. Given the down-regulation of Xnot-2,
Xbra, and gsc transcripts in embryos in which
Xqua function has been disrupted, it is not surprsing that
notochord development is impaired in these embryos.
|
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
RNA-binding properties of pXqua
Our experiments show that pXqua, which contains a single KH motif,
can bind RNA in vitro. This is also true for S3 (Urlaub et al. 1995
)
and the GSG protein SAM68 (Wong et al. 1992
; Taylor and Shalloway 1994
;
Wang et al. 1995
), which also contain single KH motifs. However, most
other KH proteins require the cooperation of multiple RNA-binding
motifs for efficient RNA binding (Siomi et al. 1994
). Therefore, it was
not entirely clear how proteins with a single KH motif could bind RNA.
In pXqua the KH domain is essential but not sufficient for full
RNA-binding activity, because the carboxyl terminus is also required.
There are several possibilities to explain the necessity of the
carboxy-terminal region. The carboxyl terminus may contain an
RNA-binding motif that cooperates directly with the KH domain for RNA
binding. This seems unlikely, however, because extensive sequence
comparisons of the carboxy-terminal region have detected no known
RNA-binding motifs. On the other hand, we have demonstrated that pXqua
can homodimerize, and it is possible that this is an essential
precondition for RNA binding. This argument is supported by the
observation that addition of
D to pXqua inhibits RNA binding,
presumably owing to the formation of
D/pXqua
heterodimers. Deletion of the carboxyl terminus of pXqua may remove or
disrupt sequences essential for dimerization thereby inhibiting
RNA-binding activity.
The proteins FMR1, FXR1, and FXR2, all of which have two KH motifs, can
homo- and heterodimerize with each other (Zhang et al. 1995
), although
it is not known whether this interaction is required for RNA binding.
It has been proposed that GSG proteins may be involved in
protein-protein interactions (Jones and Schedl 1995
; Musco et al.
1996
), and our pXqua studies provide the first demonstration of
homodimerization in this class of protein. It is possible that
homodimerization is a general feature of GSG proteins, explaining how
they can effectively bind RNA with only one KH domain. If
dimerization-dependent RNA binding is a general feature of GSG
proteins, then, in addition to elements in the carboxy-terminal region
of pXqua, it is reasonable to suggest that sequences within the
conserved GSG domain might also be involved in protein interactions.
Structural analysis of the GSG-type KH domain predicts an extended loop
region that is absent in typical KH motifs, and it is speculated that
this loop may be involved in protein-protein interactions (Musco et
al. 1996
). The
D mutant, in which the first part of the KH core
domain is deleted, still dimerizes with pXqua, indicating that this
region is not essential for protein-protein interactions. The loop
region that is conserved between GSG family members is left intact in
the
D mutant and therefore remains a prime candidate for a
dimerization motif. We are currently mapping the protein interaction
domains of pXqua and investigating the relationship between
dimerization and RNA binding.
Subcellular distribution of quaking
We have shown that pXqua is distributed between the nuclear and
cytoplasmic compartments of the cell and that the nuclear localization
signal (NLS) is contained within the last 60 amino acids of the
protein. Examination of the carboxyl terminus does not reveal a
recognizable NLS although the last 60 amino acids contain a
concentration of basic residues that are often found in the NLS. In
mouse, the 5-, 6-, and 7-kb qkI mRNAs generate the QK1-5,
QK1-6 and QK1-7 proteins, respectively, which are identical except for
the extreme carboxy-terminal sequences (Ebersole et al. 1996
). Recent
immunolocalization studies in mouse brain tissue using antibodies
specific for each of the three distinct QK1 carboxy-terminal regions
show that QK1-5 (equivalent to pXqua357) is detected in the
nucleus and cytoplasm, whereas QK1-6 and QK1-7 are almost exclusively
cytoplasmic (Hardy et al. 1996
). These observations are consistent with
our results; furthermore, it appears that the alternative
carboxy-terminal regions regulate the subcellular location of the QK1
proteins. Because the last 60 amino acids of the mouse and
Xenopus 5-kb quaking sequences are identical (Zorn et
al. 1997
), the NLS of pXqua357 (QK1-5) is likely to reside in
the last 30 amino acid residues that are alternatively spliced. It will
be interesting to determine whether the different isoforms can
heterodimerize and if so, what effect this has on their subcellular
distribution and hence their function.
Xqua is essential for notochord development
The earliest embryonic expression of Xqua occurs in the
chordamesoderm of the dorsal blastopore lip. This region of tissue, which is known as the organizer, is particularly interesting because it
differentiates into the notochord, has neural-inducing activity, has a
major role in embryonic patterning, and is responsible for the
morphogenic movements of gastrulation. To our knowledge, this is the
first example of an RNA-binding protein that is expressed in the
vertebrate organizer region and its major derivative, the notochord. To
date, expression of qkI mRNA in the chordamesoderm of the
mouse embryo has not been reported, but expression studies on early
embryos have been limited. Our experiments show that ectopic expression
of Xqua does not cause notochord differentiation at ectopic
locations, but it can enhance the development of notochord tissue,
suggesting that Xqua is probably involved in the maintenance of the differentiation process rather than determination of notochord cell fate. Similar phenotypic effects, that is, increased notochord development and subsequent enlargement of the hindbrain, have been
observed from overexpression of the Xnot-2 homeobox sequence, which is also normally expressed in the organizer and notochord (Gont
et al. 1996
). In our experiments, blocking endogenous Xqua function by overexpression of the dominant interfering Xqua protein,
D, inhibits the differentiation of the notochord, demonstrating that Xqua is essential for this process. Furthermore, the
neural inducing properties of the
chordamesoderm/organizer are inhibited in these embryos,
resulting in little or no anterior neural tissue. Phenotypically
similar aneural embryos are observed when formation of the
chordamesoderm/organizer is inhibited by UV irradiation of fertilized Xenopus eggs (for review, see Kao and Danilchik 1991
). Analysis of early gene transcripts suggests that the phenotypic effects of
D overexpression can be explained by a down-regulation of essential mRNAs such as Xnot-2, Xbra, and gsc and
possibly many others. Based on comparisons to the mouse
bracyhury mutation (Herrmann et al. 1990
) and the zebrafish
floating head (zebrafish Xnot) mutations (Talbot et
al. 1995
), down-regulation of Xbra and Xnot mRNAs
could largely account for the observed phenotype. Interestingly, some
of the qke embryonic lethal mutant mice have axial
defects and failure of head development (Justice and Bode 1988
), with a
phenotype reminiscent of the Xenopus embryos resulting from
overexpression of mutant
D protein. These qke
phenotypes could be explained, by analogy with our results, if quaking also functions in mammals to maintain chordamesoderm
development and its embryonic organizer activity.
The role of quaking in vertebrate development
Our overexpression experiments have focused on the role of pXqua
in the development of the chordamesoderm and notochord. These tissues
are the sites of earliest Xqua expression in the embryo and
are therefore the most easily disrupted in overexpression studies.
Whereas our experiments show that Xqua function is critical for
notochord development, quaking is expressed in a number of different embryonic and adult tissues and is therefore likely to be
required for the differentiation or development of many cell types. The
later embryonic expression of Xqua in the head, heart, and
somites is similar to the pattern of qkI expression observed
in mouse embryos (Ebersole et al. 1996
) and correlates well with the
diminished head folds, disorganized somites, and malformed hearts
observed in qke mutant embryos (Justice and Bode
1988
). The high levels of Xqua expression in the developing
central nervous system, particularly in the proliferating and actively
differentiating layers of the developing brain where the neuronal and
oligodendrocytes originate, are exactly where qkI expression
is detected in the mouse neonatal brain (Ebersole et al. 1996
) and are
consistent with the myelination defects observed in
qkv mice (Sidman et al. 1964
; Samorajski et al.
1970
). Recent immunostaining studies show a dramatic reduction of QK1
(equivalent to pXqua357) protein levels in oligodendrocytes
and Schwann cells of qkv mutant mice, compared with
wild-type mice (Hardy et al. 1996
). The reduction of QK1 is directly
correlated with the dismyelination defect and suggests that lack of the
QK1 protein, and hence lack of QK1 function, prevents proper
differentiation of myelinating cells. This observation parallels our
experimental results where inhibition of pXqua357 function by
overexpression of pXqua mutants results in an inhibition of notochord
differentiation.
Although more information is needed to define the biochemical function
of quaking, available evidence suggests that it regulates expression of
transcripts essential for differentiation of some cells. KH proteins
have been implicated in a diversity of processes at all levels of RNA
metabolism although in most cases their precise biochemical functions
are unclear. Because pXqua is present in both cytoplasmic and
nuclear components, we should consider a role for the protein in each
compartment. Interestingly, some abnormalities in RNA metabolism have
been observed in the neural tissue of qkv mutant
mice. Proportions of particular alternatively spliced mRNA isoforms of
myelin-associated glycoprotein, MAG (Fujita et al. 1988
; Braun
et al. 1990
; Bartoszewicz et al. 1995
), and myelin basic protein,
MBP (Carnow et al. 1984
), are altered in qk mice, whereas other mRNAs are unaffected. These observations are consistent with the experimental results indicating that blocking Xqua
function prevents the accumulation of Xnot-2, Xbra, and
gsc transcripts. The fact that levels of all three tested
marker transcripts were reduced suggests that pXqua somehow regulates a
number of different mRNAs. It is also possible that quaking may act
more generally by regulating global mRNA levels in mesodermal and
neural cells. Although the mechanism of action is unknown, available
evidence suggests that quaking regulates mRNA stability, processing, or both and that blocking quaking function prevents specific mRNAs from
accumulating to detectable levels.
| |
Materials and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Production of synthetic mRNA and proteins
PCR with Vent polymerase (NEB) was used to generate
deletions of the Xqua357 coding sequence, starting with
pSKXqua8c cDNA as a template (Zorn et al. 1997
). Fragments were cloned
into the expression vector pT7TS (a modified version of pSP64T; Krieg
and Melton 1984
) or pT7TS-HA, which provides an amino-terminal HA
epitope tag. Templates pT7TS-Xqua357,
pT7TS-Xqua365, pT7TS-HAXqua357, and the Xqua
deletion constructions were linearized with BamHI and
transcribed with T7 RNA polymerase. pSPXMax4 (Tonissen and Krieg 1994
)
was linearized with BamHI and transcribed with SP6 RNA
polymerase. pXef1 (Krieg et al. 1989
) was linearized with EcoRI and transcribed with T7 RNA polymerase. pFR, encoding
the Xenopus fibroblast growth factor (FGF) receptor (a gift
from Dr. E. Amaya, Wellcome/CRC Institute, Cambridge, UK), was
linearized with PstI and transcribed with SP6 RNA polymerase.
pXK1 encoded the Xenopus hnRNP K (Siomi et al. 1993a
).
Synthetic capped mRNA was synthesized as described (Krieg and Melton
1984
) or with the Mega-Script kit (Ambion) using cap analog (NEB).
35S-labeled proteins were translated in vitro in reticulocyte
lysates (BRL or Promega).
RNA binding assays
RNA binding of in vitro translated proteins was performed
essentially as described by Swanson and Dreyfuss (1988)
. Binding reactions used 105 cpm of labeled protein and 30 µl of
RNA-agarose resin (10-60 µg of RNA) in 0.5 ml of binding buffer
(10 mM Tris-HCl at pH 7.5, 100 mM NaCl, 2.5 mM MgCl2, 0.5% Triton X-100, and 0.1 mg/ml of BSA) for 10 min with rocking at 4°C. The
beads were washed five times with ice-cold binding buffer. Proteins
bound to the RNA-agarose were released by boiling in SDS-protein
sample buffer, resolved on SDS-PAGE, and visualized by fluorography.
Homopolymer RNA-agarose was purchased from Sigma. Total
Xenopus embryonic-agarose was generated as follows: RNA at 1 mg/ml in water was biotinylated with photoactivated
biotin-acetate (Vector Labs) according to manufacturers instructions,
and RNA-biotin was bound to streptavidin-agarose resin (BRL) at a
final concentration of 0.1-2 µg of RNA per 10 µl of agarose
resin.
Immunoprecipitation
Approximately one-fifth of the labeled proteins generated in a translation reaction were incubated with 5 µg/ml of monoclonal antibody 12CA5 (Boehringer Mannheim) and 20 µl of protein A-agarose (Sigma) in IP buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl at pH 7.5, 150 mM NaCl, 5 mM MgCl2, 1 mM EDTA, 0.25% NP-40, 1 mM PMSF, and 1 mM DTT) for 2 hr at 4°C with rocking. After precipitation, pellets were washed three times in ice-cold IP buffer and specifically bound proteins were eluted by incubation in 50 µl of 1 mM HA peptide (YPYDVPYA) (a gift from Dr. T. Kouzarides, Wellcome/CRC Institute, Cambridge, UK) at room temperature for 15 min. Precipitated proteins were resolved on 10% SDS-PAGE and visualized by fluorography.
GST fusion protein binding assays
The Xqua357 coding sequence was cloned in-frame with GST in the vector pGEX-3X. GST-Xqua or GST alone (a gift from Dr. P. Lavender, Wellcome/CRC, Cambridge, UK) was expressed and purified on glutathione-Sepharose. Approximately one-fifth of the labeled proteins generated in a translation reaction were incubated with 2 µg of GST-Xqua or GST alone coupled to glutathione-Sepharose in 500 µl of binding buffer (25 mM HEPES at pH 7.5, 12.5 mM MgCl2, 150 mM KCl, 20% glycerol, 0.1% NP-40, 1 mM DTT, and 1 mg/ml of BSA). Following 1-hr incubation at room temperature, the Sepharose was pelleted and washed four times in NETN (20 mM Tris at pH 8, 100 mM NaCl, 1 mM EDTA, and 0.5% NP-40). The bound proteins were resolved on 12.5% SDS-PAGE and visualized by fluorography.
In situ hybridization, immunocytochemistry, and histology
Embryos and explants were fixed in MEMFA (Hemmati-Brivanlou and
Harland 1989
) for 2-3 hr and then stored in methanol at
20°C. Whole-mount in situ hybridization w