|
|
|
Vol. 14, No. 3, pp. 313-327, February 1, 2000
Genes and Development Group, Department of Biomedical Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH8 9XD Scotland, UK
| |
Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In Xenopus laevis zygotic transcription begins at the midblastula transition (MBT). Prior to this the genome is organized into chromatin that facilitates rapid cycles of DNA replication but not transcription. Here we demonstrate that DNA methylation contributes to the overall transcriptional silencing before MBT. Transient depletion of the maternal DNA methyltransferase (xDnmt1) by anti sense RNA during cleavage stages is associated with a decrease in the genomic 5-methyl-cytosine content and leads to the activation of zygotic transcription approximately two cell cycles earlier than normal. Hypomethylation allows the early expression of mesodermal marker genes such as Xbra, Cerberus, and Otx2, which are subsequently down-regulated during gastrulation of the xDnmt1-depleted embryos. The temporal switch in gene expression may account for the appearance of body plan defects that we observe. Loss of xDnmt1 can be rescued by the coinjection of mouse or human Dnmt1 protein. These results demonstrate that DNA methylation has a role in the regulation of immediately early genes in Xenopus at MBT.
[Key Words: 5-methylcytosine; Xenopus; DNA methyltransferase; antisense RNA; MBT]
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The idea of a heritable, but alterable, switch on
DNA has an obvious appeal as it could allow for the regulation of a
repertoire of genes during embryo development. One candidate for this
role as a global modifier of gene activity in vertebrates is DNA
methylation, the pattern of which can be inherited in a relatively
stable form in somatic cells (Colot and Rossignol 1999
). DNA
methylation near promoters or enhancer elements leads to the stable
inactivation of the associated gene in vitro and in vivo (Bird 1992
;
Kass et al. 1997a
,b
). Methylated CpG pairs act as specific ligands for transcriptional repressors (MeCP1 and MeCP2) leading to stable gene
inactivation (Jones et al. 1998
; Nan et al. 1998
). Methyl groups are
introduced onto cytosine by enzymes known as DNA methyltransferases (Dnmt), which have been cloned and characterized in many species (Colot
and Rossignol 1999
). At least three paralogs of this family exist in
mouse (Okano et al. 1998
) and the most abundant and metabolically active protein, Dnmt1p, was originally characterized as a maintenance methyltransferase (Bestor and Ingram 1983
). Hemimethylated DNA is the
favored substrate for Dnmt1p, but it also has significant de novo
methyltransferase activity in vitro (Pradhan et al. 1997
).
DNA methylation is necessary for normal mouse development as embryos
homozygous for a loss-of-function mutation
(Dnmt1n/n) in the DNA
methyltransferase gene die in midgestation (Li et al. 1992
), showing
evidence of developmental delay and aberrant expression of imprinted
genes (Li et al. 1992
, 1993
). Complex changes in DNA methylation
patterns occur during mouse development and cell differentiation that
involve a genome-wide demethylation during cleavage followed by a wave
of de novo methylation in the growing embryo (Monk et al. 1987
; Razin
and Kafri 1994
). These changes have often been correlated with
hypomethylation at tissue-specific loci in the different somatic
lineages. However, this view has been challenged by a recent study that
showed that many tissue-specific gene promoters are not methylated or
expressed in early embryos (Walsh and Bestor 1999
). In the case of
mammals, it is argued that DNA methylation only has a role in
specialized processes such as the maintenance of X-inactivation or
imprinting in somatic cells. An examination of
Dnmt1n/n mouse embryos has not
clarified this point because the observed phenotypes are complex (Li et
al. 1992
; Lei et al. 1996
; Trasler et al. 1996
).
Xenopus laevis has a CpG methylation system similar to that of
mammals, but relatively little is known about the dynamics of DNA
methylation during development. There is no evidence for a global
demethylation, imprinting, or inactivation of sex-specific chromosomes
in Xenopus (Thiebaud et al. 1984
; Tymowska 1991
; Yamada et al.
1999
). The low efficiency of nuclear transplantation experiments (Gurdon et al. 1975
), very similar to that in mammals, suggests that
epigenetic mechanisms may have a role in determining nuclear competence
during Xenopus development.
A period of global transcriptional silence is observed between
formation of the activated egg and the midblastula in
Xenopus. There are probably several separable events that
regulate this developmental switch (known as the midblastula transition
or MBT) when there is as much as a 50-fold increase in the
transcription of some genes after the 12th cleavage division (Newport
and Kirschner 1982a
,b
). Experimental evidence suggests that
initially chromatin assembly, facilitated by the large pool of maternal
histones, is dominant over the construction of the basal transcription
complex (Prioleau et al. 1994
; Almouzni and Wolffe 1995
) and prevents gene activation. Approaching MBT, the competition at promoters can be
reversed in favor of the transcription complex when the maternal
histone store is lowered and the replication of DNA becomes coupled
with histone synthesis. We are interested in whether DNA methylation
can contribute to gene silencing before the MBT in Xenopus
embryos. An X. laevis oocyte form of DNA methyltransferase (xDnmt1) has been cloned and the identified protein is highly homologous to Dnmt1 proteins from other vertebrates (Kimura et al.
1996
). However, the expression pattern of the xDnmt1 gene and
its requirement during embryogenesis have not been established. We
cloned a partial cDNA (1.4 kb) corresponding to the conserved methyltransferase catalytic domain and used it as a probe to follow the
expression of xDnmt1 throughout development. Double-stranded RNA hybrids (caused by antisense RNA injection) in Xenopus
embryos are eliminated by endogenous nuclease activity leading to the loss of the endogenous mRNA and its associated protein (Lombardo and
Slack 1997
; Steinbeisser et al. 1995
). Our results show that antisense
RNA depletes the maternal xDnmt1 but not the zygotic form of
the enzyme, leads to hypomethylation of the genome during the first
embryonic cleavages, allows the inappropriate activation of
developmentally decisive genes, and affects the early events of cell
differentiation at the onset of gastrulation.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Expression of xDnmt1 during Xenopus development
We isolated a 1.4-kb somatic xDnmt1 clone,
xDnmt1p9/19, by screening a stage 20-22 cDNA
library (Fig. 1A). The clone had an open reading
frame of 373 amino acids and showed 98% identity with the
carboxy-terminal catalytic domain of the full-length (1490 amino acids)
oocyte form of xDnmt1 (Kimura et al. 1996
). The protein motifs
VIII, IX, and X that are essential for enzyme activity are identical
between the somatic and oocyte forms of xDnmt1 (data not
shown).
|
Northern blot analysis with a xDnmt1p9/19 probe shows that xDnmt1 or related transcripts are present throughout development (Fig. 1B, top). An mRNA of 5 kb is observed as an abundant maternal transcript in the mature oocyte and egg. After midblastula (stage 8.5) and during gastrulation (stage 12) the maternal xDnmt1 mRNA is replaced by a somatic form that is present at low levels between stages 16 and 23 and increases at stage 36 (late tadpole). The relative changes in xDnmt1 mRNA levels during development are compared with that of ubiquitously expressed ornithine decarboxylase gene (ODC) in Figure 1B.
For a more detailed analysis of xDnmt1 expression patterns,
whole-mount in situ hybridization was performed on eggs and embryos from various stages. The majority of the maternal xDnmt1
transcript localizes to the animal pole in the egg and early blastula
but is hardly detectable in the vegetal pole (Fig. 1C-E). To test whether the differential localization of xDnmt1 transcripts in cleavage stage embryos is not an in situ hybridization artifact and
reflects the distribution of methyltransferase protein in the early
embryo, xDnmt1p was immunoprecipitated from extracts derived
from dissected animal and vegetal halves of the 64-cell blastulae.
Western analysis with a monoclonal anti-Dnmt1p antibody (see Materials
and Methods for details) of the immunoprecipitated material reveals
that xDnmt1p is very abundant in the extract of animal hemisphere cells
and virtually undetectable in the vegetal counterpart (Fig. 1K, top).
In contrast proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) is present in
equal amounts in both the animal and the vegetal cell extracts (Fig.
1K, bottom). The zygotic form of the xDnmt1 transcript in
stage 12.5 gastrulae can be observed in the deep cells of the dorsal
and ventral mesoderm (Fig. 1F) and in the presumptive neural ectoderm
during neurulation (Fig. 1G). Generally, a similar pattern of
expression is maintained during the tailbud and tadpole stages (Fig.
1H-J). Comparable whole-mount in situ studies in mouse and zebrafish
have shown a very similar localization of Dnmt1 and persistently high
levels of methyltransferase in neural lineage cells (Goto et al. 1994
; Martin et al. 1999
). It is conceivable that xDnmt1 is actually expressed in all cells at varying levels, but this will require a more
detailed analysis of individual tissues.
Depletion of maternally expressed xDnmt1
To determine whether the maternal methyltransferase is essential for early development, animal or vegetal regions of the early embryo were injected with sense or antisense RNA derived from the pxDnmt1-9/19 cDNA clone. Control and injected embryos were cultured until the equivalent of the tadpole stage 35 and monitored during this time for their phenotypic appearance. Alternatively, they were collected at early to midblastula and gastrula stages and analysed for the presence of xDnmt1 RNA and protein.
Figure 2A summarizes the results of the microinjection experiments. Animal blastomeres were targeted first as this is where we observed the highest levels of xDnmt1 mRNA. The injection of 520 pg per cell of sense RNA into the animal pole of two- and four-cell blastulae had no noticeable effect on embryo survival or appearance when compared with noninjected controls (Fig. 2D,E). In contrast significant developmental abnormalities appear when antisense xDnmt1 RNA is injected into two- and four-cell embryos at a dose of >120 pg per cell. Embryos injected with 520 pg of antisense exhibit considerable delay in closing the blastopore in comparison with control embryos of the same stage (Fig. 2B,C). When they were allowed to develop further, doses of 400 and 520 pg of antisense led to the appearance of a microcephalic phenotype (Fig. 2F) in some cases accompanied by axis truncation (Fig. 3F). A considerable number of the antisense-injected embryos die during gastrulation and neurulation (Fig. 2A). An even more severe effect was caused by injection of 400 pg of antisense RNA into each of the animal blastomeres of 8- and 16-cell stage where 90% of the embryos at stage 35 either exhibit severe developmental defects or arrest at gastrulation and neurula stages. To test whether the effect of the antisense was specific to animal blastomeres, 520 pg of this RNA was injected into the each vegetal cell of four- and eight-cell blastulae. The vast majority of these developed normally.
|
|
To test whether the injection of xDnmt1 antisense RNA leads to loss of the endogenous maternal transcript we performed quantitative RT-PCR reactions with a pair of primers overlapping the junction of sense and antisense RNA (see Fig. 1A). Fig. 3A shows that 600 pg of antisense RNA per cell injected into each animal pole blastomere of 2- and 4-cell embryos is sufficient to decrease the level of the maternal xDnmt1 transcript to <5% of that detected in the normal 64-cell blastula.xDnmt1 protein is also barely detectable in the depleted blastula stage embryos (Fig. 3B). At gastrula, to our surprise, both xDnmt1 mRNA and protein are upregulated in the antisense injected embryos (Fig. 3A,B). These results were also confirmed by in situ hybridization with a 5' xDnmt1 probe (Fig. 3C,D). The unstable antisense RNA does not appear to interfere with the zygotically expressed form of xDnmt1, as the xDnmt1 transcript and protein appear at much higher levels in the antisense injected gastrulae (see Fig. 3A,B) compared with the normal embryos. It is clear that a transient depletion of xDnmt1 during blastula stages causes developmental abnormalities and sets in motion a series of events that results in subsequent changes in the pattern of expression of the zygotic form of xDnmt1.
Rescue of the antisense xDnmt1 RNA phenotype
To ascertain whether the phenotype of xDnmt1 depleted
embryos is due to the loss of methyltransferase activity we attempted to rescue the antisense embryos by coinjection of antisense
xDnmt1 RNA with either human or mouse Dnmt1 proteins (Pradhan
et al. 1997
) into the animal hemisphere of two- and four-cell
blastulae. Coinjection with hDnmt1p or mDnmt1p reverses the antisense
RNA effect in a dose-dependant manner (Fig. 4A).
hDnmt1p (4 pg) cannot change the mutant phenotype of the antisense
injected embryos (Fig. 4B), whereas 12 pg of hDnmt1 or mDnmt1 can
restore their appearance in 85-90% of the cases (Fig. 4C). In the
remaining cases (5-10%) the rescue is only partial where the embryos
have normal heads but still exhibit axis defects (Fig. 4D). This
suggests that either cross-species methyltransferase protein cannot
completely substitute for the function of xDnmt or,
alternatively, that the endogenous concentration and distribution of
xDnmt1p cannot be properly mimicked by microinjection of recombinant
proteins. Higher amounts of hDnmt1 (40 pg of protein per embryo)
coinjected with the antisense xDnmt1 RNA result in embryos
that develop posterior defects very similar to these caused by an
injection of 12 pg of hDnmt1 protein alone into the cells of the
vegetal hemisphere (Fig. 4F). When injected into animal pole cells, 12 pg of hDnmt1 protein causes a "no-axis" phenotype (Fig. 4E) and
there is a failure to develop past gastrulation. The injection of a
comparable amount of BSA had no effect on development in normal or
mutant embryos. These experiments imply that, to a large extent,
xDnmt1p function can be substituted by cross-species DNA
methyltransferases during Xenopus embryo development. In
addition higher than normal levels of Dnmt1 proteins cannot
be tolerated either by the animal or vegetal cells of the embryo.
|
DNA methylation levels in normal and antisense xDnmt1-injected embryos
We wished to know whether loss of the xDnmt1 transcripts
leads to changes in DNA methylation levels during the cleavages of the
antisense injected depleted embryos. A 5-methyl-cytosine
(m5C) monoclonal antibody (Reynaud et al. 1992
; Tweedie et
al. 1997
) was used as a probe for the methylation content in DNA
isolated from various stages of normal and antisense RNA-injected
embryos along with control DNA samples from Xenopus blood,
sperm, and the yeast, Saccaromyces cerevisiae. As expected,
the antibody detects Xenopus blood and sperm DNA samples from
the normal embryos but the signals progressively decreases towards
gastrulation (64 cell and stage 7) and is restored to the initial
levels at late neurala stages. We did not observe any global
demethylation and remethylation of DNA during these particular stages
(Fig. 5A, C, WT); if such an event takes place then
it may occur prior to the 64 to cell stage or alternatively in a
specific subset of cells in the developing embryo. The latter
possibility is supported by our observation that DNA derived from the
animal pole cells is up to three times more methylated than the
equivalent sample of vegetal pole from 64- to 128-cell blastulae (Fig.
5A,C), which correlates with the polarized localization
of xDnmt1 transcripts and protein in the cleavage stage
embryos (see Fig. 1D,K). More detailed analysis will be required to
clarify the significance of these differences in methylation levels
between distinct subsets of cells in the pre-MBT Xenopus
embryo. In contrast to the controls, the antibody was almost unable to
detect the sample from stage 7 antisense injected embryos DNA although
it could detect the 64-cell stage and stage 12 samples (Fig. 5A,C, AS).
Later stages (19-35) gave a signal that was comparable to and even
slightly higher than that of the control embryo samples. The blot was
stripped and reprobed with a mixture of total Xenopus and
yeast DNA to illustrate the equal loading of DNA on the filter (Fig.
5B). We obtained similar results using methylation-sensitive
restriction enzymes (data not shown). The observed changes in
m5C content appear to reflect changes in xDnmt1 mRNA
and protein levels in both normal and xDnmt1-depleted embryos.
|
Depletion of xDnmt1 leads to premature activation of transcription at MBT
Because DNA methylation is known to repress transcription via the
binding of transcriptional repressors, we asked whether the
abnormalities in development that we see might be due to the premature
gene activation through a global hypomethylation. Zygotic transcription
usually initiates at stage 8.5 (also known as MBT) of development. As a
test of transcriptional activation, we measured the incorporation of
-35S-labeled UTP in control, sense, and antisense
xDnmt1 RNA-injected blastulae and gastrulae (Fig.
6A,B). In each case RNA was prepared from three sets
of staged embryos (15 embryos per time point) that had been
microinjected with
-35S-labeled UTP. The control and
sense-injected embryos did not incorporate label above background
levels until stage 9 of development (Fig. 6A). In contrast we detected
up to a fourfold increase in incorporation of
[
-35S]UTP much earlier in the xDnmt1-depleted
embryos at stage 7, but the level of activation is <50% of that
seen at stage 9 for control, sense-, and antisense-injected embryos
(Fig. 6, cf. A and B). This experiment led us to conclude that
xDnmt1-depleted embryos initiate zygotic transcription
approximately two cell cycles before MBT. To determine which type of
genes, either transcribed by RNA polymerase I, II, or III, contribute
to the increased incorporation of [
-35S]UTP in
antisense-injected blastulae we made use of the differential sensitivity of RNA polymerases to the inhibitor,
-amanatin. Low concentrations of
-amanatin (0.2 µg/ml) inhibit
RNA polymerase II transcription only, and this led to a 50-60%
decrease in
-35S]UTP incorporation in both normal and
antisense-injected embryos (Fig. 6A,B). A higher dose of
-amanatin
(20 µg/ml), which inhibits the transcription of RNA
polymerase II and polymerase III, decreased [
-35S]UTP
incorporation to about 15-20% of that seen in the absence of the drug
in both types of embryos, the remaining incorporation probably
corresponds to RNA polymerase I transcription. The changes of
[
-35S]UTP incorporation that we observe suggests that
all three types of RNA polymerases (and their associated genes) are
activated in the xDnmt1-depleted embryos, which implies that
there might be a general relaxation in chromatin structure that allows
transcription to occur. In normal blastulae it is known that
embryogensis is dependent on specific transcriptional cascades that are
set in motion after MBT by maternally stored factors (Harland and
Gerhart 1997
), it is possible that this process has been disrupted by loss of DNA methylation. The net result of hypomethylation of DNA is
that many genes, at least half of which are RNA polymerase- II-regulated, are not activated in their proper developmental context.
|
Analysis of gene expression in methylation-depleted embryos
We attempted to identify some of the transcripts that appear
prematurely in the xDnmt1-depleted embryos by focusing on the expression level of mesoderm-specific molecules, ubiquitous
and tissue-specific genes. RT-PCR analysis demonstrated that in
xDnmt1-depleted embryos the transcripts for the secreted
signaling peptide Cerberus (Bouwmeester et al. 1996
) and the
transcription factor Xbra (Smith et al. 1991
; Bouwmeester et
al. 1996
) are both present at detectable levels at stage 7 (Fig. 6C).
The maternally expressed transcription factor Otx2 (Pannese et
al. 1995
) is also up-regulated. We could not detect any transcripts
that belong to tissue-specific genes such as muscle-specific
actin or neural
-tubulin (data not shown), nor
could we detect any discernible change in the abundance of the
heterochromatin proteins (HP1)
and
in the
xDnmt1-depleted embryos (Fig. 6C). The transcripts for linker
histones H1 and B4 were also present in equal amounts
in both control and antisense-injected embryos (data not shown). If
there is a change in the expression of ubiquitously expressed genes
then it is much less dramatic than that detected for the
mesoderm-inducing molecules when compared to the control transcripts of
EF1
and H4.
Whole-mount in situ hybridization on normal and depleted embryos at
stage 7-7.5 was used to localize some of the up-regulated transcripts
(Fig. 7A-C) in comparison with the nonexpressing
control blastulae (Fig. 7D). In the antisense-depleted embryos,
Cerberus transcripts are nonuniformly detected in the most
anterior region of the animal pole cells (Fig. 7A). Xbra
expression does not coincide with that of Cerberus but is
present at the lateral dorsal area of the animal hemisphere (Fig. 7B).
Neither gene was ectopically expressed in the vegetal cells (Fig. 7C).
This localized pattern of both transcripts in
the xDnmt1-depleted embryos resembles their expression
during later stages of gastrulation in normal embryos (Bouwmeester et
al. 1996
), as they appear to be at the right place in the maternal
morphogen gradient in a nonoverlapping pattern. In addition, injection
of antisense xDnmt1 RNA into a single dorsal animal cell (D1)
of eight-cell blastulae allows ectopic expression of Xbra
(Fig. 7F,G) and Cerberus (Fig. 7I,J) in subsets of cells that
are depleted of methyltransferase (Fig. 7E- -G,I,J). The activation of
Cerberus, Xbra, and Otx2 occurs despite the
fact that all of the repressive chromatin components that we analyzed are still present. Overall our analysis suggests that only genes whose
promoters normally respond to maternally stored transcription factors
are induced by changes in DNA methyltransferase activity.
|
We also found that the mesodermal markers Cerberus,
Xbra, and Otx2 are down-regulated at the equivalent
of mid-gastrulation (stage 12) in the mutant embryos (Figs. 6D and
7L,M). In normal gastrula embryos there is prominent staining for
Xbra around the blastopore, which is considerably reduced in
the xDnmt1-depleted siblings (Fig. 7M, cf. AS and WT). The
same is observed for Cerberus expression in the mutant embryos
(Fig. 7L). The diminished expression of essential mesodermal markers
and the appearance of microcephalic and axis-truncated phenotypes in
the antisense injected embryos suggests that both anterior and
posterior parts of the mesoderm are affected by the deficiency of
xDnmt1 during blastula stages. This by itself can lead to the
decreased expression of the posterior homeobox gene Hox B9 and
tissue-specific markers such as neural
-tubulin in stage
15 neurula (Fig. 6E). At the same time we saw up-regulation at gastrula
of the major Xenopus histone deacetylase gene (RPD
3), HP1
, and, as noted earlier, the zygotic form of DNA methyltransferase (Figs 6D and 3A). The fact that most of the
transcripts that show higher than normal levels belong to proteins
associated with heterochromatin formation suggests that they might be
regulated by a common pathway involving prematurely activated genes.
We also tested the expression of mesodermal and tissue-specific markers at mid-gastrula in the antisense-injected embryos that had been rescued by the coinjection of hDnmt1p (Fig. 6F). In all cases the expression of the analyzed genes was restored to wild-type levels with the exception of Otx2, which was always reproducibly higher in the rescued embryos.
The DNA methylation pattern of the Xbra promoter in normal and antisense-depleted embryos
We decided to test whether the premature activation of Xbra
can be correlated with changes in the pattern of methylation of its
promoter region (Artinger et al. 1997
; Latinkic et al. 1997
). Sequence
analysis indicates that there is a considerable number of CpGs
clustered around either the transcription initiation site (Fig.
8A) or an upstream region that is
essential for the dose-dependent response of Xbra to
TGF
-activin (Latinkic et al. 1997
). We analyzed the sequence from
267 to +203 using a methylation-dependent PCR assay (Singer-Sam et
al. 1990
) that has been modified for the use of one forward and two
reverse primers (see Fig. 8A). The longer 470-bp PCR product spans
three restriction sites for enzymes (1 HpaII and 2 HhaI sites) that are inhibited by CpG methylation. When DNA is
digested with HpaII and HhaI and subjected to PCR amplification, the longer PCR product will appear only if the sites are
methylated. The shorter PCR product does not traverse the restriction
sites but will appear at a higher molar ratio upon digestion because of
the unbalanced concentration of the reverse PCR primers (see Materials
and Methods). The degree of methylation is indicated by the ratio of
the 470-bp (methylated) versus 249-bp (nonmethylated) PCR products,
which can be calculated from a standard curve that was generated by
using a cloned Xbra promoter substrate with known levels of
CpG methylation. (Fig. 8B,C)
|
Applied to normal embryos the methylation-sensitive PCR analysis
indicated that the HpaII and HhaI sites are gradually
hypomethylated during gastrulation following Xbra expression
(stage 9-13; Smith et al. 1991
) and remain relatively free of
methylation until stage 23 (Fig. 8D). In the xDnmt1-depleted
embryos the pattern of methylation is different as the HpaII
and HhaI sites are already hypomethylated at stage 4 and at
stage 7, which coincides with the premature activation of Xbra
(Fig. 8E). These sites also become remethylated earlier (Fig. 8D and E,
cf. Stage 15 and 23 of normal and depleted embryos, respectively). The
reduced expression of Xbra in gastrula stage (st. 11) mutant
embryos may, in part, be due to de novo methylation of promoter
proximal CpGs, but this may also result from the loss of other factors
that are necessary for Xbra expression. Although we are
looking at whole-embryo DNA, the changes in methylation that we observe
in normal embryos are consistent with the idea that these sites are
hypomethylated as a consequence of gene activation. More copies of the
promoter become hypermethylated after Xbra expression is
restricted to a smaller population of cells in the late-stage embryo. A
graph representing the methylation changes that we observe over the
Xbra promoter is shown in Figure 8G. We obtained similar
results by Southern blotting (data not shown). In brief the
Xbra promoter undergoes developmentally programmed changes in
DNA methylation that are disrupted in the xDnmt1-depleted embryos. The experimentally induced hypomethylation of the
Xbra promoter correlates with its premature activation.
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
xDnmt1 and DNA methylation in Xenopus development
In this paper we attempted to determine the temporal and spatial
pattern of xDnmt1 expression during Xenopus
embryogenesis and found that xDnmt1 mRNA is present at all
stages of development albeit at varying levels. The transcript is very
abundant in the mature oocyte and persists at high levels in cleavage
stage embryos but is nonuniformly localized to the animal pole
blastomeres. After MBT the maternal xDnmt1 is replaced by a
zygotic form with considerably lower expression levels. DNA derived
from animal blastomeres is up to three times more methylated than DNA
from the vegetal pole cells. The functional relevance of this
observation is supported by the fact that vegetal blastomeres are less
sensitive to injection of antisense xDnmt1 RNA. Depletion of
the maternal xDnmt1 transcript and protein from the animal
pole leads to severe developmental defects that can be largely rescued
by cross-species (mouse or human) Dnmt1 proteins. Higher levels of
Dnmt1 protein cannot be tolerated either by the animal or by the
vegetal blastomeres. Transient depletion of maternal xDnmt1
from Xenopus blastulae affects gene activation at MBT and most
probably alters the ability of animal blastomeres to undergo neural
induction during gastrulation and subsequent differentiation. Unlike
the observation in rodents (Monk et al. 1987
), but similar to zebrafish
(Macleod et al. 1999
), we do not detect a dramatic DNA demethylation
step during the early stages of development in whole embryos. Overall
m5C content decreases toward MBT coinciding with the
initiation of zygotic transcription and generally follows the decrease
of xDnmt1 levels. This suggests a passive mechanism of
demethylation of Xenopus blastula DNA rather than the
involvement of a demethylase activity.
Contribution of methylation to transcriptional silencing before MBT
The MBT is a complex event that occurs at stage 8.5 of
Xenopus development and is associated with major changes in
the cell cycle, the appearance of cell cycle checkpoints and initiation of zygotic transcription (Newport and Kirschner 1982a
; Howe and Newport
1996
). A number of studies have demonstrated that in the early embryo,
chromatin assembly efficiently competes with binding of transcription
factors to the promoter elements (Prioleau et al. 1994
; Almouzni and
Wolffe 1995
). This competition can be experimentally shifted in favor
of transcription either by prebinding of transcription factors to
microinjected reporter templates (Prioleau et al. 1994
; Almouzni and
Wolffe 1995
) or by treatment of cultured blastomeres with a high
concentration of TGF (Kinoshita et al. 1993
). Toward MBT the decrease
in histone concentration and the coupling of their synthesis to the
cell cycle allows transcription to be initiated at a specific nucleus
to cytoplasm ratio (Newport and Kirschner 1982b
). Somatic linker
histones have been shown to play a role in differentiated gene
expression (Bouvet et al. 1994
; Kandolf 1994
) and in the duration of
mesodermal competence during gastrulation (Steinbach et al. 1997
)
whereas the contribution of maternal linker histone, H1M, to overall
transcriptional silencing before MBT is unknown.
Recent studies (Jones et al. 1998
) and our own observations (R. Meehan
and I. Stancheva, unpubl.) have found that Xenopus oocytes and
early embryos contain a considerable amount of the methylation specific
transcriptional repressor protein MeCP2. This methyl-CpG binding
protein acts as a global transcriptional repressor in two ways, either
directly inhibiting binding of transcription factors to methylated
promoters (Nan et al. 1997
) and at the level of chromatin via
interaction with Sin3A/histone deacetylase complex (Jones
et al. 1998
; Nan et al. 1998
). Mutation of the MeCP2 gene also
causes embryonic lethality in mice but there are no reports that there
is a failure of X-inactivation or inappropriate expression of imprinted
genes in these mutants (Tate et al. 1996
). It is probable that
MeCP2 in mice and Xenopus is performing a similar function.
In our experiments transient depletion of maternal xDnmt1 RNA
and protein by antisense RNA injection dramatically decreases the
content of m5C during the rapid early cleavages. Presumably
hypomethylation leads to the exclusion of MeCP2 from chromatin and
allows premature gene activation. Interestingly, as suggested by
[
-35S] UTP incorporation in the presence of
-amanitin, xDnmt1-depleted blastulae can activate the
genes transcribed by all three RNA polymerases approximately two cell
cycles before MBT (stage 6.5). Our limited RT-PCR analysis allowed us
to identify upregulated mRNAs for the mesoderm inducing molecules
Cerberus, Xbra, and Otx2, however none of
these genes can be characterized as being tissue specific in their
expression patterns at this stage of development (Smith et al. 1991
;
Pannese et al. 1995
; Bouwmeester et al. 1996
). The symmetrical
injection of antisense xDnmt1 RNA into both blastomeres at
two-cell stage and the ectopic injection into a single animal dorsal
blastomere (D1) showed that Cerberus and Xbra
transcripts appear in nonoverlapping population of cells and that their
patterns of expression greatly resemble that of normal gastrulae (Smith
et al. 1991
; Bouwmeester et al. 1996
). This is consistent with the idea
that the Xenopus embryo is prepatterned by maternal gradients
of transcription factors and morphogens before MBT (Heasman 1997
).
Additional experiments are required to identify the full spectrum of
genes that are activated in xDnmt1-depleted Xenopus blastulae.
The phenotypes of xDnmt1-depleted embryos during gastrulation
and at the equivalent of stage 35 suggest that loss of methylation during cleavage stages cannot be completely compensated by even higher
than normal levels of zygotic methyltransferase. In addition the
mesodermal markers Cerberus, Xbra, and Otx2
are down-regulated during gastrulation, when normally they are highly
expressed (Smith et al, 1991
; Pannese et al, 1995
; Bouwmeester et al,
1996
). One possibility is that loss of methylation and premature
expression of genes causes inappropriate timing of mesoderm induction
and leads to negative interference of signalling pathways. On the other
hand, we do not know how essential is the loss xDnmt1 and respectively of the initial methylation patterns for the ability of
animal pole blastomeres to differentiate since this potential must also
be set up before MBT (Kinoshita et al. 1993
). Disturbed gastrulation
movements of antisense-injected embryos suggests that they face serious
signaling problems. Despite this fact, they seem to divide in an
indistinguishable fashion compared with wild-type siblings before
gastrulation (R. Meehan and I. Stancheva, unpubl.). It also cannot be
excluded that premature gene activation may affect the cell cycle and
lead to the appearance earlier than usual of cell cycle checkpoints,
which results in untimely apoptosis and cell death.
Does DNA methylation have a conserved role in regulation of developmental gene activation?
At present it has been demonstrated that mice, zebrafish, and frog
contain abundant oocyte forms of Dnmt1. Loss or inhibition of
the enzyme during early stages is either lethal or leads to abnormal
development (Li et al. 1992
; Lei et al. 1996
; Martin et al. 1999
). The
maternal forms of Dnmt1 in zebrafish and Xenopus are
both present at high levels in the animal pole in oocytes, eggs, and
animal blastomeres during early cleavages (Martin et al. 1999
; this
study). The polarized localization reflects the general uneven
distribution of maternal cytoplasm factors that is essential for
mesoderm induction both in Xenopus and zebrafish (Wolpert et
al. 1998
). Oocyte xDnmt1 is almost equally distributed in the
nucleus and cytoplasm (Kimura et al. 1999
) and RNA transcript levels
drop dramatically after the breakdown of germinal vesicle (R. Meehan
and I. Stancheva, unpubl.; see also Fig. 1). In mice there is no
compartmentalization of the oocyte cytoplasm and the adjustment of
nuclear levels of Dnmt1 enzyme is achieved by migration of the
protein during oocyte maturation (Carlson et al. 1992
; Mertineit et al.
1998
). In the course of embryo development in all species
Dnmt1 transcripts were found at persistently high levels in
the cells of neural origin, an observation that still remains
functionally unclear (Goto et al. 1994
; Martin et al. 1999
). It has
been argued that in mice DNA methyltransferase is not essential for the
early embryonic cells. Mouse ES
Dnmt
/
cells are viable in
culture but die upon differentiation (Lei et al. 1996
). Somatic DNA
methylation patterns in mouse embryos are established after a wave of
genome-wide demethylation during preimplantation (Monk et al. 1987
;
Razin and Kafri 1994
; Panning and Jaenisch 1996
). Such dramatic changes
in m5C levels were not detected at the onset of gastrulation
in Xenopus and zebrafish (Macleod et al. 1999
; this study).
The asymmetric localization of components derived from the maternal
cytoplasm and Dnmt1 itself in these species may allow
differential methylation patterns to be set up in subsets of cells
during the cleavage stages. These patterns will be modified and
reinforced by the localized differential expression of the zygotic
Dnmt1 during later stages of development. Despite the
considerable differences that exist between mammalian development and
that of amphibia and fish, it is clear that reduced levels of
Dnmt1 and DNA hypomethylation at the onset of embryogenesis
result in equally severe phenotypes that bear distinguishable
similarities between the different species as indicated by the presence
of axial defects, failure to form neural tissue, and improper
patterning of the somites (Trasler et al. 1996
; Martin et al. 1999
). In
Xenopus and zebrafish, mesoderm formation is negatively
affected during gastrulation by hypomethylation and some genes such as
Cerberus, Otx2, Xbra, and the zebrafish floating head and the brachyury homolog no tail
(Martin et al. 1999
) are expressed at reduced levels. We show here that
maternal xDnmt1 in Xenopus is essential for
maintenance of gene silencing before midblastula transition and that
changes in xDnmt1 levels affect differentiation of animal pole
blastomeres. Our studies of the Xbra promoter revealed that it
undergoes developmentally regulated changes of DNA methylation that
coincide with the timing of Xbra expression. Bird (1992)
has
produced elegant models for transcriptional repression by DNA
methylation that depend on a number of parameters: (1) the strength of
the promoter; (2) the number and location of methylated CpG pairs; and
(3) the presence of methyl-binding proteins that can interact with
heterochromatin promoting factors. In this dynamic view of
methylation-mediated gene inactivation there is a shifting balance
between activation and repression, which depends on the presence of
strong transcription factors to activate a methylated gene. Such a
scenario may be the normal mode of gene activation during development.
Unfortunately this question has not been answered in mice because of
the complexity of Dnmt
/
phenotypes, which is greatly dominated by the negative effect of
misexpression of imprinted genes and X-chromosome inactivation (Panning
and Jaenisch 1996
). We also find that hypomethylation of
Xenopus blastulae DNA does not lead to aberrant expression of
tissue specific genes, which supports similar observations in mice
(Walsh and Bestor 1999
). It is possible that many more aspects of the
methylation repression machinery are conserved between mammals and amphibia.
| |
Materials and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cloning of xDnmt1 cDNAs
A stage 20-22 Xenopus
ZapII cDNA library was
screened with a pair of [
-32P]dATP end-labeled
oligonucleotides corresponding to the carboxy-terminal xDnmt
sequences: 3811-3831, TTCCAGAGGCAGATTCGTGG and 4271-4291, ACACTCACCACACGATGC. The longest xDnmt1 clone (GenBank
accession no.: AF192996) p9/19 containing a 1.4-kb insert
in pBluescript SK+ was sequenced and used as a hybridization probe for
Northern blot analysis and for synthesis of sense and antisense RNA. A partial 830-bp cDNA xDnmt1 p59/889 corresponding
to the oocyte xDnmt1 (Kimura et al. 1996
) amino-terminal
sequences between base pairs 59 and 889 was obtained by RT-PCR
amplification (TrueSprinter RT-PCR kit, Hybaid Ltd.) from
Xenopus oocyte RNA using the following primers: (f)
ACTGTGTCCTGTTGATTCGC, (r) TTCTTCCGCATCAGACCG. The RT-PCR product
was cloned into StuI site of pCS2+ plasmid.
Embryos and microinjections
Xenopus embryos were obtained from in vitro-fertilized
wild-type and albino eggs, grown and microinjected according to the standard procedures. Staging was according to Nieuwkoop and Faber (1967)
. Blastulae (2-, 4-, 8-, and 16-cell) were injected with 120, 400, 520, and 600 pg of antisense RNA per cell or 520 pg of sense
capped RNA synthesized in vitro from xDnmt p9/19
(T3/T7 Cap-Scribe kit, Boehringer) RNA was injected into
the amimal or vegetal half of the embryos as far as possible from the
midline. The ectopic injections of 250 pg of sense or antisense
xDnmt1 RNA coinjected with 100 pg of cytoplasmic
-gal
sense RNA were performed into the D1 blastomere of albino eight-cell
stage embryos (n = 150). The hDnmt1 and mDnmt1
baculovirus-produced proteins (Pradhan et al. 1997
) were diluted in
sterile water to a final concentration of 1, 3, and 8 ng/µl or in a sterile water containing 130 ng/µl (final concentration) antisense xDnmt1
RNA prior to microinjection.
Whole-mount in situ hybridization
The whole-mount in situ hybridizations were performed as described
(Harland 1991
). Digoxigenin-UTP or fluorescein-labeled probes were
prepared using Boehringer reagents. Xbra probe derived from
psp73 plasmid (Smith et al. 1991
), Cerberus probe was
synthesized as described (Bouwmeester et al. 1996
), and xDnmt1
3' and 5' probes were made from xDnmt1
p9/19 and xDnmt1 p59/889,
respectively.
-Gal staining was performed as described previously
(Steinbach et al. 1997
).
Northern blot analysis
RNA isolation and Northern blots were carried out according to the standard procedures.
RNA (15 µg) from each stage were loaded on the gels. The blots were
hybridized with 1.4-kb xDnmt1 cDNA
[
-32P]dCTP-labeled probe after stripping the filters
with Xenopus ODC probe (Isaacs et al. 1992
). The signals were
detected by conventional autoradiography and by FLA 2000 FluoroImager
(FujiFilm) and IP reading, quantified by Aida 2.0 (Advanced Image
Digital Analyser) software (FujiFilm, Ltd.), and plotted using
Microsoft Excel.
Whole embryo run-on experiments
Pigmented two-cell-stage embryos were coinjected with 520 pg of
antisense or sense xDnmt1 RNA and 50 nCi
[
-35S]UTP (400 Ci/mmole, Amersham) and
cultured in 4% Ficoll, 0.2× Marc's Modified Ringers or in the same
buffer containing either 0.2 µg/ml or 20 µg/ml
-amanitin in parallel with the control siblings injected with 50 nCi [
-35S]UTP only. Starting
from stage 4, samples of 15 injected and control embryos were collected
at each time point and frozen at
20°C prior to being processed.
Total RNA was purified by the use of PureScript RNA isolation kit
(Gentra) and 3 aliquots of 10 µl from each sample (final volume of
50 µl) were immobilized on glass fiber filters (GF/A) (Whatman).
The filters were washed subsequently with ice-cold 20%, 10%, and 5%
trichloracetic acid. Incorporated label was detected by a Liquid
Scintilation Analyzer 1900CA (Packard).
RT-PCR analysis
Total RNA (1 µg) from normal and xDnmt1-depleted
embryos was treated with RNase free DNase RQ1 (Promega) and reverse
transcribed with SuperScript II (BRL Life Technologies). cDNAs were
subjected to serial dilutions and with control primers for
EF1
(Wilson and Melton 1994
) or Histone H4
(f:GGGATAACATTCAGGGTATC, r:CATGGCGGTAACTGTCTTC) to estimate the linear
range of PCR amplification. The other pairs of RT-PCR primers were:
xDnmt1 amino-terminal (f: TCTTGTGGATGAATGCGAGG, r:CCACATCATCCTTCCTCT),
xDnmt1 sense/antisense overlap (f:GGCGGTGCAAGGACATTG, r:ACTGGTAGCCCATGCGTAC),
HP1
(f: CTCAGAGGAGCATAACACTTGG,
r:CCTTCTTCATTCAGACACACA),
HP1
(f:CAAGAAGGTGGAGGAAGC, r:CCAGAGGATGAAGCACAATAAA),
RPD3 (f:ACGGTGATGGTGTTGAGG; r:AGCAACGAGCCACATTCC),
Xbra (f:TGGCTTATTCCTAATGGTGG, r:CTGGCTGTGACTCATTGG),
Cerberus (f:TCATAAGAGCAACTTCCACC, r:TGCTGATTGGTTGTTAGTCC),
Otx2 (f:TACCTGAGTCCAGAGTCC, r:CTGCTGGTAGGTCATAGG),
HoxB9 (f:TACTTACGGGCTTGGCTGGA, r:AGCGTGTAACCAGTTGGCTG),
HoxB3 (f:ATATGATGAGCCACGCAGCAG, r: CAGATGCTGCAGCTCTTTGGC),
Neural
-tublin (f: ACACGGCATTGATCCTACAG, r:
AGCTCCTTCGGTGTAATGAC),
muscle actin (f: GCTGACAGAATGCAGAAG, r: TTGCTTGGAGGAGTGTGT).
Amplification was performed for Xbra, Otx2,
Cerberus, HoxB9, and RPD3 (35 cycles) and
for Histone H4, HP1
and
, EF1
(28 cycles). PCR reactions were analyzed in 1.2% agarose gels and directly scanned by FLA 2000 FluoroImmager (FujiFilm). All RT-PCRs were repeated at least three times for every set of primers and RNAs
and were also peformed in the absence of reverse transcriptase (
RT).
Immunological detection of m5C
DNA was isolated from 25-50 staged wild-type,
antisense xDnmt1 RNA-injected embryos or from ~250 stage
6 wild-type blastulae that had been separated into animal and vegetal
halves. DNA (5 µg) from each sample was digested with
EcoRI and transferred to Z-probe membrane (BioRad). Dot blots
were probed for m5C as described (Reynaud et al. 1992
;
Tweedie et al. 1997
) using a monoclonal m5C antibody and a
secondary anti-mouse HRP conjugated IgG. Chemiluminiscence signal (ECL
reagents, Amersham, Life Technologies) was detected by exposure to Fuji
XR films and by scanning with FLA 2000.
Methylation-sensitive PCR analysis
PCR quantification of methylation at the Xbra promoter was
based on a method described by Singer-Sam et al. (1990)
and modified for the use of three primers. Total genomic DNA from staged normal and
xDnmt1-depleted embryos was digested to completion with
HpaII and HhaI restriction enzymes or with
MspI. The complete digestion was monitored by removing a
portion of the reaction at time zero and incubating it with a control
plasmid (pBluescript SK+). After digestion the samples were
phenol-chloroform, chloroform extracted, ethanol precipitated, and
resuspended in distilled water to a final concentration of 100 ng/µl. Undigested DNA samples were tested for linear
amplification range with both pair of primers (see below) as a measure
of equal template concentration and by the combination of all three
primers that gave linear amplification. Competitive PCR reactions (100 µl) typically included 2 µl of HpaII, HhaI,
or MspI-digested genomic DNA (20 ng), 7 pmoles of forward
primer, 5 pmoles of first reverse primer (249), and 7 pmoles of second
reverse primer (470). The following amplification cycles were used:
denaturing at 95°C for 30 sec, annealing for 30 sec at 51°C,
1-min elongation at 72°C, 35 cycles. Xbra promoter primers
were as follows: forward CAATCAGCAGTTGCCTCAC; 1st reverse CTTCGTAACACACAGACTGG; 2nd reverse ACCTTCCATTCTTAGTGACG. To create a
quantitative standard curve a plasmid containing the Xbra
promoter and part of the first Xbra exon (Latinkic et al.
1997
) was methylated in vitro by SssI methylase (2 hr with
addition of SAM after the first hour of incubation). Methylated plasmid
(mXbra) was mixed with unmethylated Xbra plasmid in
combinations (vol/vol) 10:0, 8:2, 6:4,
4:6, 2:8, and 0:10-, all of the mixtures were digested either with HpaII and HhaI or with MspI, and
10 ng of each mixture were used for PCR amplification as described
above. All reactions were ethanol precipitated, dissolved in 15 µl
of 1× loading buffer, and electrophoresed in 1.2% agarose gel
containing 0.5 µg/ml ethidium bromide. The gels were
scanned by FLA 2000 Fluoroimmager (475 nm excitation index) and the
intensity of both 249-bp and 470-bp PCR products was determined by Aida
2.0 software as a peak function in approximate units (AU). The ratio of
470-bp to 249-bp PCR products were plotted versus % of methylation (% mXbra in the reaction) for each mixture sample. The standard
curve was used to quantify the relative % of methylation for the
endogenous genomic Xbra promoter sequences by plotting
470/249 values from the agarose gels scans of each
reaction for wild type and xDnmt1-depleted embryos against the
standard. Each series of PCRs was repeated at least 3 times.
Protein extracts and immunoblots
Total protein extracts were prepared from staged wild-type eggs,
wild-type and antisense xDnmt1-depleted blastulae and
gastrulae as described (Evans and Kay 1991
) run in 7%
SDS-polyacrylamide gels and electrotransfered to PVDF membrane.
xDnm1 was detected by a polyclonal antibody raised against the
conserved carboxy-terminal domain of mouse Dnmt1 (Liu et al.
1998
), PCNA was detected by a monoclonal PC 10 antibody (Waseem and
Lane 1990
). Anti-mouse or anti-rabbit HRP-conjugated IgGs were used as
secondary antibodies. For the immunoprecipitation experiments, protein
extracts were prepared from ~200 wild-type 64-cell blastulae, which
had been dissected to animal and vegetal halves. The
immunoprecipitation was performed according to the standard procedures.
Sepharose-proteinA beads were washed extensively with buffer containing
50 mM Tris, at pH 7.5, 150 mM NaCl, 1% NP-40, and
0.5% Na deoxocholate. The bound fractions were extracted and run in
7% SDS-polyacrylamide gels. xDnmt1 protein was detected by
mouse monoclonal antibody against human Dnmt1.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
We thank Andre Brandli for the Xenopus cDNA libraries,
Tewis Bowmeister for the Cerberus plasmid, Jim Smith for the
Xbra promoter clone, Randall Moon for the Xbra and
Harry Isaacs for the ODC cDNA probes, David Turner for
pCS-c
-gal plasmid, Jean-Paul Jost for the carboxy- and
amino-terminal mDnmt1 antibodies, Benjamine Li for the monoclonal
hDnmt1antibody, Emma Warbrick for the PCNA antibody, and Alain Nevileau
for the several shipments of 5-methylcytosine monoclonal antibody and
the protocols how to use it. Human and mouse Dnmt1 proteins
were kind gift from S. Pradhan. We are grateful to Paul Krieg and to
Sally Moody for the extremely well-organized Xenopus course at
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, (1998) and helpful advice in all that
concerned embryology work. We would like to thank Adrian Bird, Jim
Allan, Sari Pennings, Colin Davey, and Carmel Reilly for reading and
comments on the manuscript. This work was supported by a grant to R.M.
from the Wellcome Trust.
The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 USC section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Received August 25, 1999; revised version accepted December 8, 1999.
1 Corresponding author.
E-MAIL Richard.Meehan{at}ed.ac.uk; FAX 44 131 650 3714.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|