|
|
|
Vol. 16, No. 17, pp. 2173-2178, September 1, 2002
1 Department of Cell Biology & Genetics, Erasmus MC, and 2 Department of Radiation Oncology, Erasmus MC-Daniel, 3000 DR Rotterdam, The Netherlands
In the early 1980s, a primary hurdle on the track
to understanding the function of a protein was the isolation of its
gene. Over the last two decades, we have seen subsequent hurdles in the
race to decipher protein function, including atomic structure resolution and the creation of viable mouse mutants, being cleared at
an ever-increasing pace. The genome surveillance protein Rad50 has now
leapt over these modern-day hurdles. In the last two years, rapid
progress has been made in understanding structural aspects of Rad50
(Hopfner et al. 2000 Rad50 is part of an evolutionarily conserved protein complex containing
Mre11 and Nbs1 (D'Amours and Jackson 2002 To derive a viable mouse Rad50 allele, Bender et al. (2002)
![]()
Introduction
Top
Introduction
Rad50S/S mice
Rad50 structure
The Mre11 complex and...
The Mre11 complex in...
Rad50S: conservation between...
References
, 2001
, 2002
; de Jager et al. 2001
). In this issue
of Genes & Development, John Petrini and colleagues report on
the phenotypes of mice carrying a hypomorphic Rad50 allele
named Rad50S (Bender et al. 2002
).
) that is referred to as the
Mre11 complex by Petrini and colleagues. The Mre11 complex has been
implicated in diverse aspects of genome metabolism that involve DNA end
processing, including cell cycle checkpoint activation in response to
DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), DSB repair, and telomere length
maintenance (Haber 1998
; Lombard and Guarente 2000
; Petrini 2000
; Zhu
et al. 2000
). All three components of the mammalian Mre11 complex are
essential for cellular viability (Xiao and Weaver 1997
; Luo et al.
1999
; Yamaguchi-Iwai et al. 1999
; Zhu et al. 2001
). However,
hypomorphic mutations in the human NBS1 and MRE11
genes cause the genome instability and cancer predisposition syndromes
Nijmegen breakage syndrome (NBS) and ataxia telangiectasia-like
disorder (ATLD), respectively (Carney et al. 1998
; Matsuura et al.
1998
; Varon et al. 1998
; Stewart et al. 1999
). In addition, two
different engineered reduced-function alleles of murine Nbs1
resulted in viable mice (Kang et al. 2002
; Williams et al. 2002
). No
viable mutations in mammalian RAD50 had been identified thus
far. This void has now been filled by the Rad50S/S mice.
![]()
Rad50S/S mice
Top
Introduction
Rad50S/S mice
Rad50 structure
The Mre11 complex and...
The Mre11 complex in...
Rad50S: conservation between...
References
took their clues from genetic analyses of the RAD50 gene from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. RAD50-deficient S. cerevisiae cells are viable but display mitotic and meiotic
phenotypes. The cells are sensitive to the DNA-damaging agent methyl
methanesulfonate (MMS) and are defective in the formation of viable
spores. Alani et al. (1990)
had isolated separation-of-function
(rad50S) alleles of RAD50 that conferred no overt MMS
sensitivity to the cells, but still blocked viable spore formation. All
of the nine different mutations that resulted in the
rad50S phenotype mapped to the N terminus of Rad50 and were
located in the vicinity of the Walker A-type ATPase domain of Rad50
(Fig. 1A). Bender et al. (2002)
mimicked
three of these mutations in mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells. Two
resulted in inviable cells, but one, a methionine substitution for
lysine at amino acid position 22 (K22M), did support cell growth. This
allele was used to derive Rad50S/S mice.

View larger version (49K):
[in a new window]
Figure 1.
Architectural features of the Rad50 protein and its
interaction with DNA. (A) Schematic representation of protein
domains in Rad50, as predicted from its primary amino acid sequence.
N-terminal and C-terminal globular domains (N and C, respectively) are
separated by a region with the potential to form an extended coiled
coil. The Walker A- and B-type ATPase domains (A and B, respectively)
and the CXXC motif in the middle of the coiled-coil region are
indicated. The three different hypomorphic mutations located in the
N-terminal globular domain and tested by Bender et al. (2002)
are
depicted. (B) Model for the architecture of the Rad50 and
Mre11 components in the Mre11 complex. Rad50 Walker A- and B-type
ATPase domains are connected by an intramolecular coiled coil. An Mre11
dimer binding to the base of the coiled-coil regions is represented by
M. The conserved CXXC motif at the distal tip of the coiled coils is
indicated. (C) Schematic representation of potential
DNA-repair functions of the Mre11 complex. The complex has been
proposed to keep DNA fragments within close proximity, either within a
sister chromatid or between sister chromatids. This tethering can occur
through multiple interactions of the zinc-hook structures by
intermolecular coordination of a zinc ion between Rad50 CXXC motifs.
A remarkable aspect of the Rad50S allele is its
dramatically different consequence at the cellular versus the
organismal level (Bender et al. 2002
). Rad50S/S
mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) show almost none of the phenotypes that might be expected of perturbed Mre11 complex function (Table 1). The cells display no growth defect, no
defect in ionizing radiation-induced relocalization of the complex, and
no hypersensitivity to DNA-damaging agents such as ionizing radiation
and mitomycin C. In addition, although NBS and ATLD cells are defective
in the ionizing-radiation-induced intra-S-phase checkpoint,
Rad50S/S cells are not (Table 1). However, even
though no overt cellular phenotype of the Rad50S
allele could be detected, its effect on mice is profound.
Rad50S/S mice are susceptible to partial embryonic
lethality. Animals that make it through birth are small, and most of
them die within three months of severe anemia caused by hematopoietic
stem cell depletion, whereas longer-lived animals are predisposed to
cancer. How to reconcile these severe phenotypes with the subtle
mutation in the Mre11 complex is a challenge, given that the complex
plays pivotal roles in diverse aspect of DNA metabolism.
|
| |
Rad50 structure |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Because a specific mutation in Rad50, K22M, causes reduced function
of the Mre11 complex, it is useful to consider the architecture of
Rad50 and the complex. Based on its primary amino acid sequence, Rad50
has traditionally been declared a member of the structural maintenance
of chromosomes (SMC) protein family, which organizes chromosomes during
their replication and segregation (Nasmyth 2001
; Hirano 2002
; Wyman and
Kanaar 2002
). The amino acid sequence of proteins in this family
suggests that they consist of N- and C-terminal globular domains,
separated by an extended coiled-coil region (Fig. 1A). The terminal
globular domains contain Walker A- and B-type ATPase domains,
respectively, that reconstitute into a bipartite ATPase domain (Fig.
1B). The combination of electron microscopy, scanning force microscopy
(SFM), and X-ray crystallography confirmed this predicted structure
(Melby et al. 1998
; Hopfner et al. 2000
; Anderson et al. 2001
, 2002
; de
Jager et al. 2001
; Haering et al. 2002
; Hopfner et al. 2002
). However,
these studies also revealed a number of highly interesting surprises.
SMC family proteins function either as homo- or heterodimers. The Mre11
complex contains a Rad50 homodimer. A previously unexpected aspect of
the architecture of the coiled-coil regions is that they do not form
intermolecular coiled coils, but intramolecular coiled coils that are
highly flexible (Fig. 1B; de Jager et al. 2001
; Haering et al. 2002
;
Hopfner et al. 2002
). The intramolecular coiled coil forms because the
predicted coiled-coil region of a single molecule folds back onto
itself. In the case of Rad50 homologs, the coiled coil is interrupted
by a conserved CXXC motif, where C stands for cysteine and X for any
amino acid (Fig. 1A). Recently, it was shown that this motif is located
at the tip of the coiled coil in an archeael Rad50 structural homolog.
It provides a dimerization domain, referred to as a zinc-hook, between
the two Rad50 coiled-coil arms by coordination of a zinc ion by the sulfhydral groups of the four cysteines (Fig. 1B,C; Hopfner et al.
2002
).
A molecular picture of the architecture of the human Mre11 complex and
its mode of interaction with DNA is now beginning to emerge. Mre11,
which has exo- and endonuclease activities (Sharples and Leach 1995
;
Paull and Gellert 1998
; Trujillo et al. 1998
), binds to the coiled-coil
regions of Rad50 near the globular ATPase domain (Hopfner et al. 2001
).
A dimer of Mre11 interacts with two Rad50 molecules, resulting in a
large globular domain from which the coiled-coil arms emanate (Fig. 1B;
de Jager et al. 2001
). An intriguing unanswered question about the
architecture of the Mre11 complex is the location of Nbs1. This
component interacts with Mre11 (D'Amours and Jackson 2002
), but
exactly how it fits in the complex is still unknown. SFM analysis of
the complex between human Rad50 and Mre11 showed that it binds DNA
through its globular domain with the arms protruding away. The complex
oligomerizes on linear DNA and can tether DNA molecules, presumably
through interactions between the tips of its coiled coils (de Jager et al. 2001
; Hopfner et al. 2002
). Importantly, oligomerization requires a
DNA end, allowing the complex to specifically tether broken DNA
molecules either within a sister chromatid or between a broken and an
intact sister chromatid (Fig. 1C).
The deleterious effects of the Rad50 K22M mutation in mice invite
biochemical analysis of the activities of the Mre11 complex containing
this mutation. Because it is located close to the ATPase domain of
Rad50, it is of interest to determine the effect of this mutation on
the nuclease activities of the complex, given that ATP stimulates the
endonuclease activity of the complex on DNA substrates containing 3'
single-stranded overhangs (Paull and Gellert 1999
; Trujillo and Sung
2001
). Effects of the mutation on the nuclease activity could impinge
on the DNA repair function of the Mre11 complex or on its involvement
in DNA damage checkpoint signaling, because the nucleolytic processing
of DNA lesions could be required to effectively signal them to the cell
cycle checkpoint machinery (Lydall and Weinert 1995
; Lee et al. 1998
;
D'Amours and Jackson 2001
).
| |
The Mre11 complex and S-phase progression |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Deficiencies in the Mre11 complex, such as those that occur in cells
derived from NBS and ATLD patients, can result in the inefficient
inhibition of DNA synthesis upon ionizing radiation treatment (Table 1;
Shiloh 1997
; Stewart et al. 1999
). This response, known as
radioresistant DNA synthesis (RDS), is indicative of the inability of
cells to fully induce an intra-S-phase checkpoint (Shiloh 1997
).
Several recent studies provide new insights into the position of the
Mre11 complex in the cascades of events that are required to protect
cells from RDS. Near the top of these cascades is the ataxia
telangiectasia mutated (ATM) protein kinase, which is defective in
patients suffering from the genome instability, and cancer
predisposition syndrome ataxia telangiectasia (AT; Khanna and Jackson
2001
). In response to ionizing-radiation-induced DSBs, ATM
phosphorylates Nbs1, which is required to inhibit DNA synthesis
(D'Amours and Jackson 2002
). Interestingly, the extent of RDS is
greater in cells from AT patients than in cells from NBS and ATLD
patients, suggesting the possibility of parallel pathways leading to
DNA synthesis inhibition that diverge at ATM (Falck et al. 2002
).
Indeed, recent evidence suggests that one branch is formed by the
ATM-dependent phosphorylation of Chk2, which results in inhibition of
DNA replication origin firing through the Chk2-Cdc25A-cyclin E/Cdk2
cascade (Falck et al. 2001
), whereas ATM-dependent phosphorylation of
the Mre11 complex is required for a parallel branch of the
intra-S-phase checkpoint (Falck et al. 2002
). An intriguing downstream
substrate in the Mre11-complex-dependent branch could be SMC1, a
component of the multiprotein cohesion complex required for
establishment of sister-chromatid cohesion during S phase (Nasmyth
2001
; Hirano 2002
). Ionizing-radiation-induced phosphorylation of SMC1
by ATM is dependent on Nbs1 and required for inhibition of DNA
synthesis (Kim et al. 2002
; Yazdi et al. 2002
). However, the results of
Bender et al. (2002)
support the argument that the checkpoint-related
functions of the Mre11 complex in Rad50S/S cells are
not significantly affected. When Rad50S/S cells were
treated with ionizing radiation they were as efficient as wild-type
cells in inhibiting DNA synthesis.
| |
The Mre11 complex in DNA repair and replication |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Given that mutations in the components of the S. cerevisiae
Mre11 complex (in which the Nbs1-like component is encoded by the
XRS2 gene) resulted in ionizing radiation sensitivity, much attention has been given over the years to defining its role in repair
of DSBs. Multiple lines of evidence suggest that the complex participates in two mechanistically distinct pathways of DSB repair: homologous recombination and nonhomologous DNA end joining (Bressan et
al. 1999
; Lewis and Resnick 2000
; Chen et al. 2001
; Huang and Dynan
2002
). The former depends on a homologous DNA template, that is, the
undamaged sister chromatid, to accurately restore the continuity of the
broken sister chromatid, whereas the latter religates DNA ends without
any requirement for a template. Important as the role of the Mre11
complex in repair of exogenously induced DSBs might be, the complex is
also pivotally important in protecting cells from spontaneous
chromosomal rearrangements (Chen and Kolodner 1999
; Myung et al. 2001
).
These latter observations are consistent with a role of the Mre11
complex in preventing genome instability during DNA replication.
Indeed, the dependence of genome duplication on homologous
recombination in general is presently a topic of vigorous
reinvestigation (Cox et al. 2000
). Evidence from genetic, cytological,
and biochemical approaches points to a possible central position of the
Mre11 complex in this link. S. cerevisiae rad50S and
mre11 nuclease-deficient alleles are synthetically lethal with
the structure-specific endonuclease Rad27/FEN1 (Moreau et al. 1999
;
Debrauwere et al. 2001
). Given the role of Rad27/FEN1 in processing
intermediates in lagging-strand DNA synthesis, these results suggest
the involvement of the Mre11 complex in this process. Furthermore, the
complex plays a role in the resolution of aberrant DNA structures that
arise when replication forks pass through repeated sequences (Cromie et
al. 2001
; Farah et al. 2002
; Lobachev et al. 2002
). In addition,
certain DSB repair pathways that are directly coupled to extensive DNA
replication, such as break-induced replication in S. cerevisiae and replication restart in phages, require Rad50 and
Mre11 homologs (George et al. 2001
; Signon et al. 2001
). Finally, the
Mre11 complex localizes to replication sites (Maser et al. 2001
), and
its presence is required to prevent the accumulation of DSBs during DNA
replication in extracts from Xenopus laevis cells (Costanzo et
al. 2001
).
Cells derived from Rad50S/S mice are not sensitive
to exogenously induced DSBs, yet they show increases in spontaneous
levels of
-H2AX foci, a marker for DSBs (Modesti and Kanaar 2001
),
and cytologically detectable chromosome breaks (Bender et al. 2002
). These phenotypes are consistent with the idea that the Mre11 complex is
important for correcting problems arising during DNA replication. If
so, Rad50S/S cells would be under continuous
genotoxic stress, which could cause the underlying phenotype of the
mice. The age-dependent attrition of cells in the bone marrow and
testis can be explained in this context because these tissues contain
rapidly proliferating cells derived from a small stem-cell compartment.
Furthermore, interference with the ability of
Rad50S/S cells to activate cell cycle checkpoints
and induce apoptosis by deletion of p53 results in an
increased life span of the mice and decreased tumor latency (Bender et
al. 2002
). This is also in accordance with the idea that reduced
function of the Mre11 complex leads to chronic genotoxicity.
| |
Rad50S: conservation between yeast and mouse? |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Based on their amino acid sequences, it is clear that components of
the yeast and mammalian Mre11 complex are highly conserved. It is
interesting, then, that the K22M amino acid change in Rad50 yields
contrasting phenotypes in yeast and mice. The differential effect is
most dramatic in meiosis: Whereas the failure to form viable spores
owing to the inability to further process meiotic DSBs is a defining
feature of rad50S yeast strains, no overt meiotic defect is
observed in Rad50S/S mice (Bender et al. 2002
).
However, in addition to differences in phenotypes, there are also
similarities, particularly with respect to telomere metabolism. In
yeast the Mre11 complex is involved in telomere homeostasis (Haber
1998
). In mammalian cells the complex has been localized at telomeres,
but a biological effect on telomeres had not been shown (Zhu et al.
2000
). Now Bender et al. (2002)
show that in
Rad50S/S tumor cells, telomere-to-telomere fusions
are increased. A more detailed analysis of the molecular nature of
these defective telomeres will undoubtedly provide new insight into the
mechanism of telomere maintenance in mammalian cells. Given the
presence of repetitive DNA sequences at telomeres and their unusual
structure (Griffith et al. 1999
), the role of the Mre11 complex might
be related to its role in resolving aberrant DNA secondary structures
arising during replication of sequences with a high propensity to form secondary structures.
The murine Rad50S allele underscores the fact that very subtle changes in protein activity can have dramatic phenotypic consequences. It also shows that even in the context of a highly conserved protein, it is not trivial to predict the behavior of mammalian mutant alleles based on yeast genetics. Two of the mimicked yeast rad50S alleles resulted in nonviable murine ES cells, whereas a third resulted in mice on the threshold of viability. The severity of the murine Rad50S phenotype caused by a subtle mutation provides a prime example of the importance of polymorphisms in genome-surveillance proteins for conferring differences in cancer predisposition in the human population. Now that a biological effect of the mammalian Rad50S protein has been shown, it is an interesting venture to link this biological effect to one or more of the many biochemical and structural functions of the Mre11 complex. Certainly, we can expect many more surprises with regard to this protein complex in the not-too-distant future, given that the keyword "Rad50" pulls up just as many references in PubMed in the last two and half years as in the preceding 23.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
3 Corresponding author.
E-MAIL kanaar{at}gen.fgg.eur.nl; FAX 31-10-408-9468.
Article and publication are at http://www.genesdev.org/cgi/doi/10.1101/gad.1025402.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. Morales, J.-W. F. Theunissen, C. F. B. Kim, R. Kitagawa, M. B. Kastan, and J. H.J. Petrini The Rad50S allele promotes ATM-dependent DNA damage responses and suppresses ATM deficiency: implications for the Mre11 complex as a DNA damage sensor Genes & Dev., December 15, 2005; 19(24): 3043 - 3054. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. de Jager, C. Wyman, D. C. van Gent, and R. Kanaar DNA end-binding specificity of human Rad50/Mre11 is influenced by ATP Nucleic Acids Res., October 15, 2002; 30(20): 4425 - 4431. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||